Background

Banana Split Sweet & Savory

Charlotte Amalie's hidden bakery gem: Sarah's fresh ice cream, flaky pies, savory wraps, and warm smiles await on Raadets Gade—a sweet-savory escape near Main Street.

Explore the guide View on map
★★★★★5

Tucked away on a quiet side street in Charlotte Amalie, Banana Split Sweet & Savory is a charming bakery and cafe run by the talented Sarah. Savor homemade ice cream, classic banana splits, flaky hand pies, savory wraps, kabobs, pot pies, and fresh soups like pumpkin. Affordable, fresh-from-scratch treats blending American, Lebanese, and Mediterranean flavors make it a must-visit hidden gem for breakfast or lunch near historic Main Street.

Plan your visit

A brief summary to Banana Split

Opening times, essentials, and a few local tips gathered into one calmer, easier-to-scan planning section.

Plan your visit

🏛
Indoor
📶
Mobile reception: 5 out of 5
Monday
9 am-5 pm
Tuesday
9 am-5 pm
Wednesday
9 am-5 pm
Thursday
9 am-5 pm
Friday
9 am-5 pm
Saturday
9 am-5 pm

Other nearby places you may find interesting

Explore places near Banana Split

    See all →

    Unlock the Best of Banana Split

    Find tickets, tours with entry, and experiences available for this location.

    Tickets & tours for Banana Split
    Banana Split

    Find the right way to book Banana Split

    See the available options, compare prices and reviews, and choose the one that fits your plans best.

    1
    See what's available
    Browse the current booking options for this location.
    2
    Compare the essentials
    Use prices, ratings, and reviews to narrow down the options.
    3
    Book with clarity
    Choose the option that matches your timing and budget.

    Buy tickets

    No tickets available

    Book tours with entry

    No tours with entry available

    Book tours without entry

    No tours without entry available

    Getting There

    Walking

    Short 5-minute walk from Charlotte Amalie waterfront or Main Street; head inland on Raadets Gade. Free, easy access.

    Public Transport

    VITRAN bus to Charlotte Amalie stops, then 3-minute walk to Raadets Gade. Fare $1-2, frequent service.

    Taxi

    Quick 2-5 minute ride from cruise port or hotels. Cost $5-10 one-way.

    For the on-the-go comforts that matter to you

    Drink Options
    Food Options
    Seating Areas
    Sheltered Areas

    Local tips

    ✓
    Try the pumpkin soup and chicken hand pie for a perfect savory lunch combo.
    ✓
    Opt for homemade waffle cones with ice cream flavors like dulce de leche.
    ✓
    Visit mid-morning to watch Sarah craft fresh pastries.

    Discover more about Banana Split

    Discovering the Hidden Gem

    Nestled on Raadets Gade in the heart of Charlotte Amalie, St. Thomas, Banana Split Sweet & Savory offers a delightful escape from the bustling Main Street. This cozy spot specializes in handmade ice cream, bakery treats, and savory delights, all crafted daily by owner Sarah using the finest ingredients. Open daily from 9am to 5pm, it's perfect for a quick breakfast pastry or leisurely lunch.

    Sweet Indulgences

    Indulge in creamy homemade ice cream served in waffle or sugar cones, or go for the namesake banana split piled high with flavors and toppings. Bakery cases brim with tarts, pies, and breads, including unique options like 5-cheese with black olives. Dulce de leche ice cream and baklava provide exotic twists amid classic confections.

    Savory Delights

    Beyond sweets, the menu shines with savory hand pies stuffed with chicken, onion and cheese; salt fish; lamb; or veggies, paired with housemade horseradish sauce. Kebab wraps feature chicken, lamb, or falafel alongside hummus. Pot pies, shepherd's pie, and daily specials like pumpkin soup round out hearty, flaky-crusted options influenced by Lebanese and Mediterranean cuisines.

    Personal Touch and Atmosphere

    Sarah's warm hospitality defines the experience—watch her prepare items fresh in the back of this air-conditioned haven. The casual, boutique vibe suits solo diners, families, or shoppers seeking respite. Affordable pricing keeps it accessible, with wraps at $18 and falafel at $12.

    Practicalities and Location

    Located steps from waterfront and historic sites like Emancipation Garden, it's easily walkable. VITRAN buses nearby make it convenient. Private events welcome. High relevance for St. Thomas visitors craving authentic, from-scratch eats in a friendly setting.

    A brief summary to Banana Split

    Use Tower Bridge as your starting point for nearby food, family ideas, nightlife, and more local discoveries.

    Best experiences near Banana Split

    Best hotels near Banana Split

    Best bars near Banana Split

    Plan around the quieter times

    A quick look at seasonal patterns and peak visiting hours.

    Busiest months of the year

    Seasonality

    Busiest hours of the day

    Footfall
    Mobile App
    Get the app

    Your all‑in‑one travel companion app

    Explore expert travel guides, compare and book tours, experiences, hotels, and more—all from the palm of your hand. Download now for seamless trip planning wherever your wanderlust takes you.

    File:US military tank on Flamenco Beach, Culebra, Puerto Rico.jpg - Wikimedia Commons

    More about Culebra

    Discover Culebra, an unspoiled Caribbean paradise with world-renowned beaches, vibrant marine life, and tranquil natural beauty, just a short trip from Puerto Rico.

    Tell me more about Culebra

    Select Currency

    Choose the currency you want prices to display in.