Background

Treasure Hunting at One Good For Another

Discover vintage treasures and unique finds at One Good For Another, New Haven's beloved consignment shop and thrift store.

★★★★★5 (12)

Explore One Good For Another, a charming consignment shop in the heart of New Haven, where vintage finds and unique treasures await. This thrift store is a paradise for treasure hunters, offering an eclectic mix of items that reflect the city's vibrant culture and history. With its welcoming atmosphere and affordable prices, it's a must-visit for both locals and tourists alike.

Plan your visit

A brief summary to One Good For Another

Opening times, essentials, and a few local tips gathered into one calmer, easier-to-scan planning section.

Plan your visit

📍
59 Broadway 2nd Floor, New Haven, Downtown, Connecticut, 06511, US
Tuesday
11 am-5 pm
Thursday
12 pm-6 pm
Friday
11 am-5 pm
Saturday
11 am-5 pm
Sunday
12 pm-5 pm
Eve
From Eve

Know before you go

Hi, I'm Eve. Here are a few practical things to know before exploring One Good For Another.

Local know-how to help you travel smarter and make the most of every moment.

Visit during weekdays for a quieter shopping experience.
Check the store's social media for updates on special sales and new arrivals.
Don't hesitate to ask staff for recommendations; they know the best finds!
Bring a reusable bag to carry your treasures home.
Take your time to explore; you never know what hidden gems you might discover.

Discover more about One Good For Another

One Good For Another is not just a consignment shop; it's a treasure trove waiting to be explored. Nestled in the bustling downtown area of New Haven, this quaint thrift store offers an eclectic mix of vintage clothing, unique home decor, and one-of-a-kind knick-knacks. The charm of this location lies in its curated collection, where every item tells a story and holds the potential to be a cherished find. From retro clothing that evokes nostalgia to quirky home accessories that add character to any space, shoppers will find a little bit of everything. The shop's friendly staff are always on hand to assist, providing insights into the history of certain items and helping you navigate through the aisles filled with treasures. A visit here is more than just shopping; it's an experience that invites you to slow down and appreciate the art of finding something special. Whether you are a local resident looking for a unique addition to your wardrobe or a tourist in search of a memorable souvenir, One Good For Another promises a delightful shopping experience. Make sure to set aside enough time to browse and uncover hidden gems, as new items are added regularly. The store's commitment to sustainability and supporting the local community makes it an ideal stop for conscientious shoppers. If you’re in the area, don’t miss the chance to experience the magic of this charming consignment shop.

Explore places near One Good For Another

    See all →

    Unlock the Best of One Good For Another

    Find tickets, tours with entry, and experiences available for this location.

    Buy tickets

    No tickets available

    Book tours with entry

    No tours with entry available

    Book tours without entry

    No tours without entry available

    A brief summary to One Good For Another

    Use Tower Bridge as your starting point for nearby food, family ideas, nightlife, and more local discoveries.

    Mobile App
    Get the app

    Your all‑in‑one travel companion app

    Explore expert travel guides, compare and book tours, experiences, hotels, and more—all from the palm of your hand. Download now for seamless trip planning wherever your wanderlust takes you.

    File:Old Campus, Yale University, New Haven CT.jpg - Wikimedia Commons

    More about New Haven Harbor

    Discover New Haven Harbor: A blend of history, stunning views, and cultural experiences along Connecticut's picturesque coastline.

    Tell me more about New Haven Harbor

    Select Currency

    Choose the currency you want prices to display in.