Best Restaurants in Eleuthera

34 restaurants

1. 
   01
   Restaurant4.5★534 reviews

   Buccaneer Club

   Nestled in the heart of Governor's Harbour, the Buccaneer Club is a culinary haven where tourists can indulge in delicious local cuisine and enjoy a vibrant atmosphere. With its moderate pricing and welcoming ambiance, it's a must-visit for food lovers.

   Mon–Tue 7:00–21:00 · Thu–Sun 7:00–21:00

   60 min drive · 30 km·5QW4+GMJ, Governor's Harbour

   Show on map Buccaneer Club
2. 
   02
   Restaurant4.5★313 reviews

   1648 - An Island Restaurant

   Nestled in the heart of Governor's Harbour, 1648 - An Island Restaurant offers a culinary journey that combines local ingredients with international flair, all while providing stunning ocean views. Ideal for food enthusiasts and casual diners alike, this upscale dining experience is a must-visit for anyone exploring the Bahamas.

   Daily 7:30–20:30

   61 min drive · 30 km·Queen's Hwy, Governor's Harbour

   Show on map 1648 - An Island Restaurant
3. 
   03
   Restaurant4.4★309 reviews

   Tippy's Restaurant and Beachside Bar

   Nestled on the stunning shores of North Palmetto Point, Tippy's Restaurant and Beachside Bar offers an unforgettable dining experience with breathtaking ocean views. Known for its laid-back atmosphere, delicious seafood, and refreshing cocktails, it's a must-visit for anyone looking to enjoy the tropical charm of the Bahamas.

   Tue–Sun 12:00–21:30

   58 min drive · 29 km·5QRR+3GW, North Palmetto Point

   Show on map Tippy's Restaurant and Beachside Bar
4. 
   04
   Grill4.5★159 reviews

   Fishbone's Beach Bar & Grill

   Nestled in the serene Blue Hole Estates of Eleuthera, Fishbone's Beach Bar & Grill offers a delightful culinary escape with breathtaking ocean views. A perfect spot for tourists seeking fresh seafood, vibrant cocktails, and a laid-back atmosphere.

   36 min drive · 18 km·Blue Hole Estates Savannah Sound Eleuthera

   Show on map Fishbone's Beach Bar & Grill
5. 
   05
   Restaurant4.3★130 reviews

   Twin Brothers

   Nestled in the heart of Alice Town, Twin Brothers is a culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. This charming restaurant is renowned for its fresh seafood and local delicacies, making it a must-visit for tourists seeking authentic Bahamian cuisine. With a warm atmosphere and friendly service, Twin Brothers invites you to indulge in delicious dishes while enjoying the vibrant culture of the Bahamas.

   110 min drive · 55 km·8GX8+R9H, Alice Town

   Show on map Twin Brothers
6. 
   06
   Restaurant4.7★102 reviews

   Mel's Snack Shack

   Discover Mel's Snack Shack, a delightful restaurant nestled in Central Eleuthera. Known for its friendly atmosphere and delicious local cuisine, it's a must-visit for tourists seeking an authentic Bahamian dining experience. With an array of mouth-watering dishes and reasonable prices, Mel's promises to satisfy your taste buds while offering a taste of local culture.

   93 min drive · 47 km·Central Eleuthera James Cistern Bahamas Eleuthera

   Show on map Mel's Snack Shack
7. 
   07
   Restaurant4.4★119 reviews

   New Sunset Inn

   Discover the New Sunset Inn, a charming restaurant that offers a delightful culinary experience in a serene setting. Perfect for tourists seeking authentic local flavors and relaxing vibes.

   58 min drive · 29 km·Queen's Hwy

   Show on map New Sunset Inn
8. 
   08
   Restaurant4.5★111 reviews

   Sammy's Place

   Nestled in the heart of Rock Sound, Sammy's Place offers a delightful culinary experience with its unique breakfast options and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Perfect for tourists seeking to savor local flavors.

   15 min drive · 7.7 km·Rock Sound

   Show on map Sammy's Place
9. 
   09
   Restaurant4.6★95 reviews

   Mate & Jenny's Restaurant & Bar

   Nestled in the heart of North Palmetto Point, Mate & Jenny's Restaurant & Bar offers a delightful culinary experience with a menu that showcases local flavors and fresh ingredients. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a lively night out, this restaurant is the perfect spot to unwind and indulge.

   50 min drive · 25 km·5R49+HJH, North Palmetto Point

   Show on map Mate & Jenny's Restaurant & Bar
10. 
    10
    Restaurant4.6★88 reviews

    3 J's Jerk Pit

    Nestled in North Palmetto Point, 3 J's Jerk Pit is a culinary gem that offers an authentic taste of Caribbean cuisine, specializing in jerk dishes that tantalize the taste buds. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, it's a must-visit for any food lover.

    50 min drive · 25 km·5R49+XPH, North Palmetto Point

    Show on map 3 J's Jerk Pit