Lost Property: Nottingham’s Quirky Secret Cocktail Bar

4.3 (471)

Discover Nottingham’s secret cocktail haven where quirky décor meets expertly crafted drinks in a captivating cave-like setting.

Tucked away on Carlton Street in Nottingham, Lost Property is a unique cocktail bar famed for its quirky, cave-like setting and inventive drinks menu. Known for its atmospheric, intimate vibe and creative décor featuring old suitcases and a penny bar, it offers a memorable night out with expertly crafted cocktails in a hidden, speakeasy-style venue. The bar’s distinctive ambiance and lively music make it a standout spot for cocktail lovers seeking something different in Nottingham’s nightlife.

A brief summary to Lost Property

5, 7 Carlton St, Nottingham, NG1 1NL, GB
Click to display
Duration: 1 to 3 hours
Mid ranged
Indoor
Mobile reception: 4 out of 5

Wednesday 7 pm-2 am
Thursday 7 pm-2 am
Friday 4 pm-2 am
Saturday 4 pm-2 am

Local tips

Arrive early on weekends to secure a spot, as seating is limited and the bar can get busy.
Try the signature cocktails like the Lost At Sea or Porn Star Martini for a unique taste experience.
Explore the lower cave bar for a more intimate and atmospheric setting, but be mindful of the damp environment.
Be prepared for a dimly lit space and a quirky, maze-like layout—perfect for adventurous visitors.
Check the cocktail menu in advance as some drinks may be unavailable on certain days due to stock.

Other nearby places you may find interesting

Lost Property

Lost Property (secret cocktail bar in Nottingham’s caves)

The Curious Tavern

Six Barrel Drafthouse

Six Barrel Drafthouse, Hockley

Getting There

Bus

Take Nottingham City Transport buses 56 or 58 from the city center; the journey takes about 10-15 minutes to a stop near Carlton Street. Services run frequently but check schedules for late-night availability. A single fare costs around £2.50.
Tram

Use the Nottingham Express Transit tram to the Lace Market stop, approximately a 10-minute walk from Lost Property. Trams run every 7-10 minutes during peak hours. Tickets cost about £2.50 for a single journey.
Taxi

Local taxis or ride-hailing services can reach Lost Property in 5-10 minutes from central Nottingham. Expect fares between £5-£8 depending on traffic and time of day. This option offers door-to-door convenience, especially late at night.
Walking

If staying nearby in Nottingham city center, walking to Lost Property takes about 10-15 minutes via paved urban streets. The route is straightforward but involves some narrow alleys, so it is best suited for those comfortable with urban exploration.

For the on-the-go comforts that matter to you

Restrooms
Drink Options
Food Options
Seating Areas
Information Boards

Lost Property location weather suitability

Any Weather
Rain / Wet Weather
Mild Temperatures

Discover more about Lost Property

A Hidden Gem in Nottingham’s Urban Maze

Lost Property is cleverly concealed down a narrow alley on Carlton Street, Nottingham, making it a true hidden gem for those in the know. Its entrance hints at secrecy and exclusivity, inviting visitors to discover a labyrinthine interior that feels like stepping into a secret world. The bar’s location inside the Mercure Nottingham City Centre George Hotel adds a historic layer, blending old-world charm with contemporary nightlife culture.

Atmosphere That Captivates and Intrigues

The venue’s atmosphere is one of its most defining features. The interior is a quirky treasure trove, decorated with vintage suitcases, a wall covered in brown labels bearing messages from past visitors, and a bar front made entirely of pennies. The lower level, known as the caves, offers a dimly lit, intimate space with mold-covered walls that add to the mysterious, underground vibe. This setting is both atmospheric and cozy, perfect for those who appreciate a unique, immersive environment.

Craft Cocktails and Curated Drink Selection

Lost Property prides itself on its cocktail craftsmanship, offering a diverse menu that includes classics like Porn Star Martinis alongside inventive creations such as the flaming Lost At Sea and sharing Long Islands. The bar also stocks a variety of spirits, wines, and beers, catering to a wide range of tastes. Despite some fluctuations in stock availability, the bartenders are known for their skill and willingness to customize drinks, enhancing the personalized experience.

Music and Vibe: A Night to Remember

Music plays a central role in shaping the bar’s lively yet laid-back vibe. The sound system delivers tunes loud enough to energize the space but still allows for conversation in the quieter seating nooks. On busy nights, the bar transforms into a social hub where patrons can dance and mingle, creating a vibrant nightlife experience. The eclectic mix of music and the venue’s intimate scale make it a memorable destination for both locals and visitors.

Challenges and Character

While Lost Property is celebrated for its uniqueness, it has faced challenges such as occasional service inconsistencies and the dampness inherent to its cave setting. Some visitors note that the atmosphere can be affected by these factors, but many find that the bar’s character and charm outweigh these minor drawbacks. Its quirky nature and hidden location mean it’s not for everyone, especially those who prefer bright, open spaces.

Community and Cultural Footprint

Over the years, Lost Property has become a cultural fixture in Nottingham’s nightlife scene, drawing a diverse crowd from cocktail aficionados to curious explorers. Its blend of historic ambiance and modern mixology reflects Nottingham’s evolving urban culture. The bar’s presence enriches the city’s social fabric, offering a distinctive spot where stories are shared, and new memories are made.