Plesters: A Boutique Seafood Experience in Sheffield

A cozy, family-run seafood and steakhouse in Sheffield’s Heeley, blending eclectic flavors with warm hospitality and a boutique vibe.

4.7

Looking to book tours, experiences or hotels? Let me help you...

Plesters is a cozy, family-run seafood and steakhouse located on London Road in Heeley, Sheffield. Known for its eclectic menu featuring surf and turf, Jamaican jerk, and fresh seafood, this restaurant offers a warm atmosphere with attentive service. Founded by Jeremy and Pansy Plester, it combines modern quality food with a personal touch, making it a popular destination for locals and visitors seeking a relaxed yet refined dining experience.

A brief summary to Plesters

631-633 London Rd, Sheffield, Heeley, S2 4HT, GB
+447591652713
Visit website
Duration: 1 to 2.5 hours
Mid ranged
Indoor
Mobile reception: 4 out of 5

Friday 6 pm-11 pm
Saturday 6 pm-11 pm

Local tips

Reserve a table in advance, especially for weekend evenings, as the intimate setting fills quickly.
Try the surf and turf or Jamaican jerk dishes for a taste of the restaurant’s eclectic menu.
Enjoy the friendly service and ask the staff for recommendations to enhance your dining experience.
Visit on a Friday or Saturday evening when the restaurant is lively and the atmosphere is at its best.

Plesters location weather suitability

Any Weather
Rain / Wet Weather
Mild Temperatures

Discover more about Plesters

A Family-Run Culinary Gem in Heeley

Plesters is a boutique restaurant nestled in the vibrant Heeley district of Sheffield, run by husband and wife duo Jeremy and Pansy Plester. With over 30 years of combined experience, they have crafted a welcoming and intimate dining environment that feels like a home away from home. The restaurant’s neat, clean, and cozy interior reflects their dedication to quality and hospitality, making it a beloved spot for both locals and visitors alike.

An Eclectic Menu with a Seafood Focus

The menu at Plesters offers a diverse range of dishes, from classic surf and turf to Jamaican jerk with rice and peas, alongside other seafood and meat specialties. The food is prepared with a modern twist, emphasizing fresh, high-quality ingredients and bold flavors. Guests often highlight the superb taste and faultless execution of dishes such as fish goujons and sirloin surf and turf, showcasing the kitchen’s skill and creativity.

Atmosphere and Service That Feels Personal

Plesters prides itself on its laid-back yet lively atmosphere. The restaurant strikes a balance between casual comfort and stylish presentation, enhanced by friendly and attentive service. Jeremy’s warm welcome and Pansy’s culinary expertise create a unique dining experience that feels personal and memorable. The space is intimate but lively, with a varied clientele that adds to its inviting character.

Location and Setting on London Road

Situated at 631-633 London Road in Sheffield’s Heeley neighborhood, Plesters benefits from a vibrant local scene. The area’s mix of residential charm and urban energy complements the restaurant’s boutique style. While the restaurant is modest in size, it offers sufficient space between tables to ensure privacy and comfort. The location is accessible and well integrated into the community, making it a convenient stop for those exploring Sheffield.

Commitment to Quality and Community

Plesters is more than just a restaurant; it is a reflection of its owners’ passion for food and hospitality. The couple’s commitment to delivering a memorable dining experience is evident in every detail, from the thoughtfully curated menu to the welcoming service. This dedication has earned Plesters a strong reputation and a loyal following, with many guests eager to return and share their experience with others.

A Destination for Seafood and Steak Lovers

Whether you are craving fresh seafood, a hearty steak, or a flavorful Caribbean-inspired dish, Plesters offers a unique blend of options that cater to diverse tastes. The restaurant’s moderate pricing and quality make it an excellent choice for a special night out or a casual meal with friends. Its boutique charm and culinary expertise position it as a standout destination in Sheffield’s dining landscape.