The Milk Pail: A Charming Market Experience
Experience the charm of The Milk Pail in Water Mill, NY, where fresh produce, homemade treats, and local flavors come together in a vibrant market atmosphere.
Nestled in the scenic Water Mill area, The Milk Pail is a delightful market that offers a variety of fresh produce, homemade goods, and local delicacies. Known for its vibrant atmosphere, this charming destination is perfect for tourists looking to experience the local flavors and community spirit of the Hamptons.
A brief summary to The Milk Pail
- 1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, New York, 11976, US
- +1631-537-2565
- Visit website
- Monday 9:30 am-5:30 pm
- Wednesday 9:30 am-5:30 pm
- Thursday 9:30 am-5:30 pm
- Friday 9:30 am-5:30 pm
- Saturday 9:30 am-5:30 pm
- Sunday 10 am-5:30 pm
Local tips
- Visit early in the day for the best selection of fresh produce and baked goods.
- Don't miss the chance to sample local cheeses and jams available at various stalls.
- Check the market’s schedule for special events or seasonal festivals during your visit.
- Bring a reusable bag to carry your purchases and support eco-friendly practices.
- Explore nearby walking trails for a full day of enjoying the natural beauty of Water Mill.
Getting There
-
Car
If you're driving, start on Montauk Highway (NY-27) from any point in The Hamptons. Follow Montauk Highway eastbound toward Water Mill. The Milk Pail is located at 1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976. Look for the sign on the right side of the highway. There is parking available on-site, but be aware that it can get crowded during peak hours.
-
Public Transportation
To reach The Milk Pail via public transportation, take the Hampton Jitney or Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) to the nearest stop in Water Mill. If you're on the Hampton Jitney, get off at the Water Mill stop, then walk along Montauk Highway for about 0.5 miles (approximately a 10-minute walk) to reach The Milk Pail. If you take the LIRR, you will need to transfer to a local taxi or rideshare service from the nearest station, which is the Bridgehampton station, as it is about 2 miles away.
-
Taxi/Rideshare
If you're already in The Hamptons and prefer a more direct route, you can use a taxi or rideshare service like Uber or Lyft. Simply enter 'The Milk Pail, 1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976' as your destination. Fares will vary based on your starting location, but expect to pay around $15-$30 for a short ride within the area.
Discover more about The Milk Pail
Iconic landmarks you can’t miss
Conscience Point Historic Site & Nature Walk
6.9 km
Discover the historical significance and natural beauty of Conscience Point, a captivating landmark in Southampton, NY, perfect for history enthusiasts and nature lovers alike.
Shelter Island Historical Society
15.7 km
Explore the captivating history of Shelter Island at the Shelter Island Historical Society, a treasure trove of local heritage and cultural exhibits.
Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum
20.2 km
Explore the rich maritime history at Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum, a historical gem on Long Island's North Fork with stunning waterfront views.
67 Steps Beach & Permit Parking
22.0 km
Discover the serene beauty of 67 Steps Beach in Greenport, NY, a perfect coastal escape for sunbathers and water sports enthusiasts alike.
Hither Hills State Park
28.8 km
Explore Hither Hills State Park - a coastal gem in Montauk, NY, offering beautiful beaches, hiking trails, and a serene escape into nature.
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
30.8 km
Experience the ultimate coastal retreat at Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, blending luxury and natural beauty in stunning Montauk, NY.
Hither Woods Preserve
31.5 km
Explore the tranquil beauty of Hither Woods Preserve in Montauk, a nature lover's paradise with stunning trails and breathtaking coastal views.
Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort
33.6 km
Experience the charm of Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort in Montauk, a perfect getaway for relaxation and exploration on New York's beautiful coastline.
Ruschmeyer's
34.3 km
Experience the charm of Montauk at Ruschmeyer's, where rustic accommodations meet vibrant nightlife in a coastal paradise.
Montauk Mountain Preserve
34.4 km
Explore the natural beauty of Montauk Mountain Preserve, a tranquil oasis of diverse ecosystems and stunning coastal views, perfect for nature lovers.
Navy Beach Restaurant, Montauk | Seafood Restaurant
34.5 km
Discover Navy Beach Restaurant in Montauk: enjoy fresh seafood, ocean views, and a vibrant dining atmosphere perfect for every occasion.
Montauk Indian Museum
34.5 km
Explore the Montauk Indian Museum to uncover the rich heritage of the Montaukett tribe in a serene coastal setting.
Second House Museum
34.5 km
Discover the rich maritime history of Montauk at the Second House Museum, a charming historic site that tells the story of the region's transformation.
Kirk Park Beach
34.7 km
Discover the beauty of Kirk Park Beach in Montauk, where golden sands meet the Atlantic, offering a perfect blend of relaxation and recreational activities.
Harvest on Fort Pond
35.0 km
Discover the culinary delight at Harvest on Fort Pond, where fresh seafood meets breathtaking waterfront views in Montauk, NY.
Unmissable attractions to see
The Hamptons
1.4 km
Explore the Hamptons: A blend of beautiful beaches, rich culture, and gourmet cuisine awaits in this New York coastal paradise.
The Water Mill Museum
2.2 km
Discover the rich history of the Hamptons at The Water Mill Museum, a captivating local history museum showcasing the region's heritage and charm.
Bridge Gardens
2.8 km
Explore the breathtaking beauty of Bridge Gardens, a serene botanical paradise in Bridgehampton, NY, perfect for nature enthusiasts and peace seekers.
Parrish Art Museum
3.1 km
Explore the Parrish Art Museum in Water Mill, NY, where contemporary architecture meets a rich collection of American art and inspiring exhibitions.
Duck Walk Vineyard
3.3 km
Experience the charm of Duck Walk Vineyard, where exceptional wines and breathtaking landscapes create unforgettable memories in the heart of the Hamptons.
The Bridgehampton Museum - The Nathaniel Rogers House
3.5 km
Explore the captivating history of the Hamptons at The Bridgehampton Museum, a cultural gem showcasing the region's rich heritage.
Flying Point Beach
3.9 km
Experience the serene beauty of Flying Point Beach in Southampton, NY, where soft sands meet sparkling waters for a perfect day of relaxation.
Children's Museum of the East End
4.2 km
Explore, learn, and play at the Children's Museum of the East End – a magical destination where imagination comes alive for kids and families.
Sagg Swamp Preserve
4.2 km
Explore the serene landscapes and diverse wildlife at Sagg Swamp Preserve, a nature lover's paradise in Sagaponack, NY.
South Fork Natural History Museum & Nature Center
4.3 km
Discover the rich natural history of Long Island at the South Fork Natural History Museum & Nature Center, perfect for families and nature enthusiasts.
Channing Daughters Winery
4.7 km
Discover the art of winemaking at Channing Daughters Winery, where local flavors and stunning landscapes await you in Bridgehampton, NY.
Sagg Main Beach
4.7 km
Discover the serene beauty of Sagg Main Beach in Sagaponack, NY, a perfect spot for sunbathing, swimming, and family fun by the Atlantic Ocean.
Wölffer Estate Vineyard
5.6 km
Experience the elegance of Wölffer Estate Vineyard, where exquisite wines meet breathtaking landscapes in the heart of Sagaponack, New York.
Long Pond Greenbelt Nature Center
5.9 km
Discover the natural beauty and educational wonders of Long Pond Greenbelt Nature Center, a hidden gem in Bridgehampton, NY that celebrates local wildlife.
Southampton History Museum
6.0 km
Explore the Southampton History Museum for an unforgettable journey through the rich history and culture of Southampton, New York.
Essential places to dine
Highway
9.1 km
Discover the flavors of New American cuisine at Highway Restaurant in East Hampton—where every dish tells a story.
Cove Hollow Tavern
11.2 km
Discover the rustic charm of Cove Hollow Tavern in East Hampton - where locally sourced flavors meet cozy ambiance.
The Living Room
12.6 km
Discover upscale American dining at The Living Room in East Hampton - where seasonal flavors meet stylish ambiance for an unforgettable meal.
Dopo Buttero
12.8 km
Experience authentic Italian flavors at Dopo Buttero in East Hampton - where every meal is crafted with passion and tradition.
1770 House Restaurant & Inn
13.0 km
Discover the perfect blend of history and modern elegance at 1770 House Restaurant & Inn in East Hampton, NY.
The Palm - East Hampton
13.4 km
Experience culinary excellence at The Palm - East Hampton, where premium steaks meet sophisticated dining in an unforgettable atmosphere.
John Papas Cafe
13.4 km
Experience the charm of East Hampton at John Papas Cafe, where delicious breakfast and lunch await you in a cozy setting.
Sant Ambroeus East Hampton
13.5 km
Experience exquisite Italian cuisine at Sant Ambroeus in East Hampton – where elegance meets authentic flavors.
East Hampton Grill
14.0 km
Experience exquisite American cuisine at East Hampton Grill, where vibrant flavors meet an inviting atmosphere in the heart of East Hampton.
Nick & Toni's
14.2 km
Discover the exquisite flavors of Italy at Nick & Toni's - East Hampton's premier destination for upscale Italian dining.
Cowfish
14.4 km
Discover Cowfish in Hampton Bays: A delightful blend of fresh seafood and American cuisine set in an inviting atmosphere perfect for any occasion.
Bostwick's Chowder House
15.2 km
Discover East Hampton’s Bostwick’s Chowder House – where fresh seafood meets coastal charm in a delightful dining experience.
Moby's
15.4 km
Experience authentic Italian cuisine at Moby's in East Hampton—where every meal is a celebration of flavor and hospitality.
Bostwick's on the Harbor
17.7 km
Discover Bostwick's on the Harbor: East Hampton's premier seafood restaurant offering stunning views and fresh local flavors.
Stone Creek Inn
21.7 km
Indulge in exquisite French-Mediterranean cuisine at Stone Creek Inn in East Quogue – where culinary excellence meets elegance.
Markets, malls and hidden boutiques
The Retreat Boutique
2.3 km
Explore The Retreat Boutique in Bridgehampton for unique thrift finds while supporting a worthy cause in a charming atmosphere.
T.J. Maxx
2.4 km
Discover unbeatable deals on clothing, accessories, and home goods at T.J. Maxx in Bridgehampton, NY - your ultimate shopping destination.
BLUE ONE
3.2 km
Explore BLUE ONE in Bridgehampton for a unique blend of stylish clothing and accessories that define coastal fashion.
ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop
5.0 km
Explore the ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop in Sagaponack for unique second-hand finds, vintage clothing, and sustainable shopping that benefits local animal welfare.
Elegant Setting
5.9 km
Explore Elegant Setting: A unique gift shop and antique store in Southampton, offering handcrafted gifts and timeless treasures for every visitor.
The Wharf Shop
9.4 km
Discover a whimsical toy store in Sag Harbor, filled with unique toys and games for all ages, perfect for creating cherished memories.
Black Swan Antiques
9.4 km
Explore a treasure trove of exquisite antique furniture and unique home decor at Black Swan Antiques in Sag Harbor, NY.
Ava's & Around Again
9.6 km
Discover the perfect blend of style and sustainability at Ava's & Around Again, a charming women's clothing and consignment shop in Sag Harbor.
Sunshine Amagansett
13.3 km
Experience the charm of Sunshine Amagansett, a boutique haven in East Hampton offering unique fashion and home decor treasures.
Aviator Nation Hamptons
13.4 km
Discover the stylish coastal vibe at Aviator Nation Hamptons – where trendy fashion meets the charm of East Hampton.
Reformation
13.4 km
Explore sustainable fashion at Reformation, where trendy designs meet eco-conscious shopping in the heart of East Hampton.
Kirna Zabête
13.4 km
Discover high-end women's fashion at Kirna Zabête, East Hampton's premier boutique for luxury and style.
alice + olivia
13.4 km
Discover the vibrant world of women's fashion at alice + olivia, the boutique that blends playful sophistication with contemporary style in East Hampton.
Unsubscribed Store
13.4 km
Explore Unsubscribed Store for chic women's clothing, beachwear, and vintage finds in the heart of East Hampton, NY.
Veronica Beard East Hampton
13.4 km
Discover a stylish women's clothing store in East Hampton, where luxury meets coastal charm, perfect for fashion enthusiasts.
Essential bars & hidden hideouts
Southampton Social Club
5.2 km
Dive into the vibrant nightlife and delicious American cuisine at Southampton Social Club, your go-to destination in Southampton, NY.
Fellingham's Restaurant Sports Bar
5.9 km
Experience the best of American cuisine at Fellingham's Restaurant Sports Bar, where family-friendly dining meets a vibrant sports atmosphere in Southampton.
North Sea Tavern
6.2 km
Discover the energetic vibe and delicious offerings at North Sea Tavern, Southampton's go-to spot for live music and dining.
The Clubhouse
9.3 km
Discover the vibrant fusion of dining, entertainment, and leisure at The Clubhouse in East Hampton, NY, where fun knows no bounds.
Murf’s Backstreet Tavern
9.4 km
Discover the vibrant nightlife at Murf’s Backstreet Tavern in Sag Harbor, where fun meets relaxation in a friendly atmosphere.
Corner Bar
9.5 km
Experience the vibrant atmosphere and delightful drinks at Corner Bar in Sag Harbor, a must-visit for any traveler exploring this charming coastal town.
BAR NONE
12.6 km
Discover the charm of Bar None in East Hampton, where exquisite wines, fresh seafood, and a vibrant atmosphere await you.
Fisherman Quarters Sportsbar
12.8 km
Discover the best of Hampton Bays at Fisherman Quarters Sportsbar, where great drinks, sports, and a lively atmosphere await.
Cittanuova
13.5 km
Experience the authentic taste of Italy at Cittanuova, a top-tier Italian restaurant in East Hampton serving delicious pizzas and traditional dishes.
Blue Parrot
13.5 km
Savor authentic Mexican cuisine in East Hampton at Blue Parrot, where vibrant flavors meet a welcoming atmosphere.
Tiki Joe’s Meschutt
14.0 km
Discover the vibrant atmosphere of Tiki Joe’s Meschutt, a tropical bar in Hampton Bays with delicious cocktails and stunning views.
MARS & EL TURCO
14.4 km
Discover the vibrant nightlife and delicious dining at Mars & El Turco, East Hampton's premier bar and restaurant destination.
Common Ground East
14.4 km
Experience the vibrant nightlife at Common Ground East, where great music and an energetic atmosphere come together for an unforgettable evening.
Rumba
14.7 km
Experience the vibrant Caribbean culture at Rumba, a premier bar and restaurant in Hampton Bays, offering fresh seafood and exotic cocktails.
Sundays On The Bay
15.0 km
Discover the flavors of American cuisine and fresh seafood at Sundays On The Bay, where stunning waterfront views meet a vibrant dining atmosphere.
