Agave - Havensight Travel Guide

Agave is a chic tequila bar and Mexican kitchen that has become a cornerstone of St. Thomas's dining scene since its founding in 2019 in Red Hook. The restaurant expanded to a second location in Havensight Shopping Mall in December 2022, bringing its signature blend of modern Mexican cuisine and world-class spirits to a prime shopping destination. The venue combines vibrant, contemporary design with warm hospitality, creating an environment where diners can enjoy authentic Mexican fare alongside expertly curated tequila and mezcal selections.

Agave specializes in original takes on traditional Mexican flavors, with particular emphasis on handcrafted elements. The kitchen prepares house-made corn tortillas, fresh salsas, and colorful crispy chips that serve as the foundation for the restaurant's signature dishes. The menu features creative tacos including Carne Asada with chimichurri steak, Carnitas with pineapple-coconut pulled pork, and Pollo with asado-marinated chicken. Appetizers highlight the Chip Trio with guacamole, salsa, and queso, along with specialties like Agave Poppers (cheese-stuffed jalapeños wrapped in hickory bacon) and Local Ceviche made with fresh mahi-mahi. Entrées include sizzling fajitas, enchiladas, and protein-forward dishes like Camarones (grilled shrimp). The restaurant also offers vegetarian options, burgers, and an array of salads featuring fresh ingredients and house-made dressings. Desserts include Churros, Caramel Apple Empanadas, and a Mexican Choco Taco.

Agave operates as a genuine tequila bar with an extensive selection of premium sipping tequilas and mezcals. The spirits program emphasizes quality over quantity, offering both entry-level and high-end options at reasonable prices. The bar crafts innovative, handcrafted cocktails with Mexican-inspired profiles, including the signature Agaverita available in multiple flavor variations such as original, spicy, strawberry, mango, passion fruit, peach, pear, and cucumber.

The restaurant runs a rotating schedule of weekly specials designed to encourage repeat visits. Margarita Monday features $8 Agaveritas and $25 pitcher options. Taco Tuesday offers street tacos at $6 for two tacos on house-made corn tortillas with choice of pollo, carnitas, or carne asada. Wine Down Wednesday features $9 red and white sangria, providing affordable options for budget-conscious diners.

The Havensight location occupies space within a shopping mall near the cruise port, resulting in a moderately noisy environment typical of high-traffic commercial areas. The restaurant maintains business casual dress code standards and operates with an 18% automatic gratuity included on checks. Service quality varies, with some guests praising attentive staff and excellent recommendations, while others have noted inconsistent attention during peak periods. The vibrant, modern aesthetic creates an energetic dining environment suitable for both casual meals and special occasions.