Pelican Key · Best Restaurants · Curated · Updated 2026

Best Restaurants in Pelican Key

Discover the best restaurants in Pelican Key. Find inspiration for your trip with our curated list of top-rated spots, local favorites, and hidden gems.

The 10 best restaurants in Pelican Key

sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/palapa-hidden-oasis-sxm

Palapa Hidden Oasis SXM

Discover the exquisite flavors of Caribbean cuisine at Palapa Hidden Oasis in Sint Maarten, where stunning views meet exceptional dining.

Airport Rd, Simpson Bay, Sint Maarten
4.6 Excellent 407 reviews
sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/pineapple-pete-restaurant

Pineapple Pete Restaurant

Experience delightful Caribbean cuisine at Pineapple Pete Restaurant in Cole Bay - where every meal is a celebration of flavor.

Welfare Rd, Cole Bay, Sint Maarten
4.4 Very Good 849 reviews
sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/topper-s-restaurant-bar

Topper's Restaurant & Bar

Experience delightful dining at Topper's Restaurant & Bar in Simpson Bay - where local flavors meet international cuisine in a vibrant setting.

60 Welfare Rd, Simpson Bay, Sint Maarten
4.3 Very Good 518 reviews
sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/sale-pepe-marina-italian-sicilian-restaurant-sxm

Sale & Pepe Marina Italian Sicilian Restaurant SXM

Experience authentic Italian cuisine with breathtaking marina views at Sale & Pepe Marina in Sint Maarten.

40 Airport Rd, Simpson Bay, Sint Maarten
4.2 Very Good 497 reviews
sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/captain-s-rib-shack

Captain’s Rib Shack

Experience authentic Caribbean cuisine at Captain’s Rib Shack in Simpson Bay – where delicious ribs and vibrant vibes await!

Simpson Bay, Sint Maarten
4.4 Very Good 560 reviews
sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/la-patrona

La Patrona

Discover exquisite Caribbean flavors and breathtaking views at La Patrona in Cole Bay - a culinary haven for every tourist.

Cole Bay, Sint Maarten
4.4 Very Good 415 reviews
sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/avantika

Avantika

Discover the vibrant flavors of Thailand at Avantika in Sint Maarten—where every dish tells a story.

68 Welfare Road, Puerta Del Sol, Simpon Bay, Sint Maarten
4.5 Excellent 565 reviews
sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/the-greenhouse

The Greenhouse

Experience flavorful Caribbean cuisine at The Greenhouse in Simpson Bay - where local ingredients meet international flair.

2WJ4+QWW, Simpson Bay, Sint Maarten
4.3 Very Good 515 reviews
sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/isola-restaurant-lounge-bar

Isola restaurant & Lounge bar

Experience authentic Italian cuisine at Isola Restaurant & Lounge Bar in Sint Maarten, where every dish tells a story.

37 Billy Folly Road, Sint Maarten
4.5 Excellent 337 reviews
sint-maarten/pelican-key/restaurant/lazy-lizard-restaurant-craft-bar

Lazy Lizard Restaurant & Craft Bar

Discover authentic Caribbean flavors at Lazy Lizard Restaurant & Craft Bar in Philipsburg - where every bite tells a story.

Behind Diamond Casino, 5 Boardwalk, Philipsburg, Sint Maarten
4.8 Excellent 360 reviews

More to explore in Pelican Key

Jump into the most useful discovery pages nearby, from experiences and heritage highlights to food, stays, shopping, and evening ideas.

File:Pelican Key, Koolbaai, Sint ...
Destination guide

More about Pelican Key

Discover Pelican Key, Sint Maarten's hidden gem with stunning beaches, luxurious resorts, and thrilling water activities. Perfect for relaxation and adventure.

Tell me more about Pelican Key
Mobile App
Get the app

Your all‑in‑one travel companion app

Explore expert travel guides, compare and book tours, experiences, hotels, and more—all from the palm of your hand. Download now for seamless trip planning wherever your wanderlust takes you.

Select Currency

Choose the currency you want prices to display in.