Best Restaurants in Rum Cay
Hungry in Rum Cay? Explore top-rated restaurants with menus, reviews, and local recommendations. Open the free web guide or Evendo app.
The best restaurants in Rum Cay
- Top rated
- Closest to the centre
- A–Z
31 restaurants
-
Grill3.8★2,082 reviews
Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville Bahamas
Nestled in the vibrant atmosphere of Paradise Island, Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville Bahamas is a tropical haven for tourists seeking a lively dining experience. With its laid-back ambiance, delicious American cuisine, and stunning waterfront views, it embodies the spirit of island life.
-
Seafood4.2★1,202 reviews
Poop Deck
Nestled in Nassau, Poop Deck is a must-visit seafood restaurant that offers a delightful culinary experience with fresh fish and breathtaking views. Enjoy the vibrant flavors of the Bahamas as you dine on the waterfront.
Daily 12:00–22:00
-
Restaurant4.4★601 reviews
Mckenzie's Fresh Fish & Conch
Nestled on the picturesque Paradise Island, McKenzie’s Fresh Fish & Conch is a culinary gem where tourists can indulge in delectable seafood dishes. This vibrant restaurant is renowned for its fresh catch and traditional Bahamian flavors, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts seeking an authentic island experience.
Mon–Thu 11:00–20:00 · Fri–Sun 11:00–21:00
-
Italian3.8★650 reviews
Carmine's
Carmine's is a celebrated Italian restaurant located in Paradise Island, Bahamas, renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and hearty family-style dishes. Perfect for tourists seeking an authentic culinary experience, this restaurant is a must-visit.
Mon 17:00–22:00 · Wed–Sun 17:00–22:00
-
Grill4.5★458 reviews
Nippers Beach Bar & Grill
Nippers Beach Bar & Grill is a vibrant beachfront destination on Great Guana Cay, offering delicious food, refreshing drinks, and stunning ocean views. This lively bar and grill is perfect for tourists looking to unwind and enjoy the tropical atmosphere.
-
Seafood3.9★604 reviews
Goldie’s Conch House
Goldie’s Conch House in Nassau is a must-visit destination for seafood lovers, offering an authentic taste of Bahamian cuisine in a vibrant atmosphere. Indulge in fresh conch dishes and immerse yourself in local culture.
-
Restaurant3.9★596 reviews
The Swimming Pig Gastropub
Nestled in the vibrant heart of Nassau, The Swimming Pig Gastropub is a must-visit destination for food lovers and social butterflies alike. With its eclectic menu and lively atmosphere, this restaurant offers a unique dining experience that showcases the best of Bahamian flavors paired with international influences. Whether you're starting your day with a hearty breakfast or winding down with cocktails in the evening, The Swimming Pig promises an unforgettable culinary journey.
Open 24 hours
-
Restaurant3.8★524 reviews
Fish by José Andrés
Nestled in the heart of Paradise Island, Fish by José Andrés offers a luxurious dining experience where seafood takes center stage. Guests can indulge in an array of exquisite dishes inspired by global flavors, all while enjoying stunning ocean views.
Mon 17:00–22:00 · Wed–Sun 17:00–22:00
-
Restaurant3.9★459 reviews
Murray's Deli
Murray's Deli offers a delightful dining experience with a casual atmosphere, perfect for tourists looking to enjoy delicious meals in the heart of Paradise Island. With a diverse menu and friendly service, it’s an ideal spot to recharge during your adventures.
-
Restaurant4.0★424 reviews
The Poop Deck at Sandyport
The Poop Deck at Sandyport is a culinary gem in Nassau, Bahamas, offering delicious seafood dishes and stunning waterfront views that captivate every visitor.
Grabbers Bed Bar and Grill
Nestled in the picturesque Great Guana Cay, Grabbers Bed Bar and Grill offers tourists a delightful dining experience with stunning views, vibrant atmosphere, and delicious local cuisine. Perfect for unwinding after a day of exploration.
Daily 11:30–21:00
Café Martinique
Nestled on Paradise Island, Café Martinique offers a luxurious dining experience with exquisite French cuisine, stunning decor, and an ambiance that is simply unforgettable. Perfect for tourists seeking a culinary delight amidst the beauty of the Bahamas.
Tue–Sat 17:30–22:00 · Sun 11:00–13:00
Pink Octopus
Nestled in the heart of Nassau, Pink Octopus is a must-visit restaurant for tourists seeking a delightful culinary experience. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and delectable dishes, this restaurant captures the essence of Bahamian flavors with a modern twist, making it an ideal spot for lunch or dinner. Whether you’re savoring fresh seafood or enjoying tropical cocktails, every bite promises to be a taste of paradise.
Daily 12:00–21:45
Pineapple Bar and Grill
Nestled in the heart of the Bahamas, Pineapple Bar and Grill is a vibrant restaurant that offers a delightful culinary experience. Known for its fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and lively atmosphere, it's a must-visit for tourists looking to savor local flavors while enjoying beautiful surroundings.
Daily 11:00–22:00
Crabs-n-Tings
Crabs-n-Tings is a delightful restaurant in Nassau, offering an authentic taste of Bahamian cuisine. Known for its friendly atmosphere and exceptional seafood dishes, it’s a must-visit for tourists seeking local flavors.
Mon–Fri 11:30–17:00 · Sat–Sun 11:30–20:30
MacDuffs
Discover the exquisite flavors and inviting ambiance at MacDuffs, a must-visit restaurant on Norman's Cay that promises a delightful dining experience.
Daily 12:00–15:00, 18:00–20:00
Emerald Sunset View
Nestled on the picturesque Great Guana Cay, Emerald Sunset View offers a delightful dining experience with breathtaking views of the Caribbean Sea. This charming restaurant combines fresh local flavors with stunning sunsets, making it a must-visit for tourists seeking an unforgettable meal in a tropical paradise.
Daily 8:00–23:30
Lukka Kairi Waterfront Bar & Grill
Nestled along the scenic Woodes Rodgers Walk in Nassau, Lukka Kairi Waterfront Bar & Grill invites tourists to indulge in a delightful dining experience. With stunning views and a vibrant atmosphere, this restaurant is perfect for enjoying fresh seafood and local flavors while soaking in the beauty of the Bahamian coast.
Daily 11:00–17:00
Wild Orchids Waterfront Restaurant
Nestled in the picturesque Rock Sound, Wild Orchids Waterfront Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with stunning views and a diverse menu that celebrates local flavors. Tourists can enjoy fresh seafood and traditional Bahamian dishes while soaking in the tranquil ambiance of this waterfront gem.
Mon–Sat 11:00–21:00
The Beach Club
Nestled in the picturesque Bullock Harbour, The Beach Club offers a delightful dining experience with stunning ocean views, a vibrant atmosphere, and a menu that celebrates local flavors. This restaurant is perfect for tourists looking to unwind and savor delicious dishes while enjoying the serene beach ambiance.
Tue–Sat 7:30–15:00
The Bush Garden Seafood & Steakhouse
Nestled in the heart of Nassau, The Bush Garden Seafood & Steakhouse offers an unforgettable culinary experience. With a menu that features fresh seafood and succulent steaks, this restaurant is a must-visit for any tourist looking to indulge in Bahamian flavors. Enjoy a vibrant atmosphere and warm hospitality that perfectly complements your dining experience.
The Midnight Spot
Nestled in the vibrant atmosphere of Potter's Cay Dock, The Midnight Spot offers a delightful culinary experience featuring local Bahamian flavors. This charming restaurant is perfect for tourists seeking to indulge in fresh seafood and authentic island dishes while enjoying the picturesque views of Nassau.
Mon–Wed 12:00–20:00 · Fri–Sun 12:00–20:00
TY´s Sunset Bar & Grill
Nestled on Little Farmer's Cay, TY's Sunset Bar & Grill offers a delightful dining experience with stunning sunset views and a menu that celebrates local flavors. Perfect for tourists looking to unwind in a tropical paradise.
Mon–Sat 10:00–18:00
Kaye's Bar
Nestled in the heart of Port Nelson, Kaye's Bar offers a delightful blend of local charm and refreshing cocktails, making it a must-visit destination for tourists seeking a taste of Bahamian culture and relaxation.
Staniel Cay Yacht Club Restaurant
Nestled in the breathtaking Bahamas, Staniel Cay Yacht Club Restaurant offers a delightful culinary experience with stunning views and fresh local seafood, perfect for tourists seeking a taste of island life.
Scorpios inn restaurant & bar
Nestled in the idyllic surroundings of Great Guana Cay, Scorpios Inn Restaurant & Bar offers an unforgettable dining experience with stunning views and delicious cuisine, perfect for tourists seeking local flavors.
Daily 9:00–20:00
Ocean View Restaurant and Bar
Nestled in the scenic Port Nelson, Ocean View Restaurant and Bar offers a delightful dining experience with stunning ocean vistas. This family-owned establishment serves up authentic Bahamian cuisine, making it a must-visit for tourists looking to indulge in local flavors while enjoying the beautiful surroundings.
Rum Cay Drive #13 (Shena's)
Nestled in the heart of Eight Mile Rock, Shena's Grill offers a unique dining experience that combines vibrant flavors with a laid-back atmosphere, making it a must-visit for tourists looking to indulge in authentic Bahamian cuisine.
The Hill House Restaurant at Fowl Cay Resort
Nestled in the stunning Fowl Cay Resort, The Hill House Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with breathtaking views and exquisite cuisine. Ideal for tourists seeking a memorable culinary adventure.
Daily 18:30–21:00
Flyin' Pig Cafe
Nestled in the heart of Staniel Cay, Flyin' Pig Cafe is a delightful culinary retreat that offers an exceptional dining experience for tourists. With a menu that features a variety of delicious options, from fresh coffee to mouth-watering dishes, this cafe is the perfect spot to relax and enjoy the beautiful surroundings.
Mon–Sat 8:00–21:00
Two Sisters Takeaway
Nestled in the heart of Port Nelson, Two Sisters Takeaway offers an unforgettable seafood experience for tourists seeking fresh, local flavors. With its charming atmosphere and a menu brimming with delicious options, this eatery is a must-visit for anyone exploring the beautiful Bahamas.
Explore Rum Cay on the map
A handpicked selection of must-see spots in Rum Cay, mapped for you.
More about Rum Cay
Rum Cay travel guide
Rum Cay in The Bahamas offers quiet beaches, salt-pond landscapes, historic Port Nelson, clear waters and rewarding diving away from resort crowds.
Tell me more about Rum CayMore to explore in Rum Cay
Best attractions in Rum Cay
Best landmarks in Rum Cay
Best shops in Rum Cay
Best bars in Rum Cay
Best nightclubs in Rum Cay
Best experiences in Rum Cay
Best hotels in Rum CayExplore more
Explore more of The Bahamas
Discover The Bahamas: A Caribbean getaway with stunning beaches, vibrant culture, and endless adventures. Perfect for relaxation, exploration, and unforgettable memories.
Explore The Bahamas
Getting your guide ready…
We are putting together a fresh copy of the Rum Cay guide. This can take up to a minute.
This can take a few moments. If your browser asks, choose Allow so the download can start. You'll find the guide in your Downloads folder.
Nothing happened? Download it again
Sorry, the guide is taking longer than usual. Please try again in a minute, or get it by email instead.
