The Devil's Advocate: Edinburgh’s Atmospheric Gastropub and Whisky Bar

A Historic Setting in the Heart of Edinburgh's Old Town

The Devil's Advocate occupies a distinctive location within an old Victorian pump house tucked away on Advocate’s Close, a narrow, stepped alley steeped in Edinburgh’s medieval charm. This atmospheric setting, with its exposed brick walls, wooden beams, and vaulted ceilings, evokes a sense of history and character that complements the Old Town’s labyrinthine streets. The venue’s interior design balances rustic textures with intimate lighting, creating a warm and inviting ambiance that feels both authentic and stylish.

A World-Class Whisky and Cocktail Destination

Home to a remarkable collection of over 300 Scottish and international whiskies, The Devil's Advocate is a magnet for whisky enthusiasts. The bar boasts an impressive whisky shelf featuring rare and award-winning selections such as the Ardbeg Uigeadail. Beyond whisky, the bartenders are acclaimed for their inventive cocktail creations, including signature drinks like the House of Advocates, which blends genever, lavender, blueberry, and botanicals. The cocktail program is dynamic and expertly crafted, appealing to both connoisseurs and casual drinkers.

Seasonal Scottish Cuisine with a Modern Twist

The kitchen emphasizes seasonal and locally sourced Scottish ingredients, offering a menu that changes regularly to reflect the best produce available. Starters such as black haggis with celeriac purée and whisky-cured salmon showcase traditional flavors with contemporary presentation. Mains include dishes like duck breast with plum and ginger sauce and expertly selected steaks from a master butcher. While the food has received mixed reviews, many appreciate the focus on quality ingredients and the pairing potential with the extensive drink offerings.

Atmosphere and Experience

The Devil's Advocate buzzes with energy, especially in the mezzanine dining area and the candlelit booths. Its location on a historic close adds a mysterious, almost literary quality, reminiscent of Robert Louis Stevenson’s Edinburgh. The venue is lively but intimate, making it a popular spot for after-work drinks, social gatherings, and whisky tastings. Outdoor seating is available, offering a charming vantage point to soak in the Old Town’s unique ambiance.

Community and Reputation

Part of the Bon Vivant Group, The Devil's Advocate shares a reputation for quality and innovation with sister venues across Edinburgh. It is well-loved by locals and tourists alike for its distinctive character and drink selection. However, some diners have noted inconsistencies in food and service, suggesting it is best enjoyed for its drinks and atmosphere rather than as a fine dining destination. Its blend of historic charm, excellent whisky, and creative cocktails makes it a must-visit for those exploring Edinburgh’s vibrant bar scene.

Unique Features and Cultural Significance

The venue’s location on Advocate’s Close situates it within one of Edinburgh’s most evocative historic passages, enhancing the cultural experience of visiting. Its extensive whisky collection pays homage to Scotland’s national spirit, while the innovative cocktail menu reflects contemporary trends in mixology. The Devil's Advocate thus serves as both a guardian of tradition and a pioneer of modern bar culture in the city.