The Smithy Cafe, Shapinsay
A community-run cafe and restaurant in a historic smithy on Shapinsay, serving Orkney fare in a warm, rustic setting with occasional evening bar service.
Tucked in the heart of Balfour on Orkney’s Shapinsay, The Smithy is a community-run cafe and restaurant housed in a historic smithy building. It serves hearty Orkney fare, local drinks, and warm hospitality in a rustic, welcoming space. Open seasonally, it’s a social hub for islanders and a charming stop for visitors exploring the island’s heritage and coastline. The relaxed atmosphere, local art, and occasional evening bar make it more than just a meal stop.
A brief summary to The Smithy Cafe
- Orkney, Balfour, KW17 2DX, GB
- +441856711243
- Visit website
- Duration: 0.5 to 2 hours
- Budget
-
Mixed
- Mobile reception: 3 out of 5
- Monday 11 am-3 pm
- Tuesday 11 am-3 pm
- Wednesday 10 am-3 pm
- Thursday 11 am-3 pm
- Friday 11 am-12 am
- Saturday 11 am-5 pm
- Sunday 11 am-5 pm
Local tips
- Check current opening hours online before visiting, as they are limited and vary by season; the cafe may be closed on some days or at short notice.
- Visit during the day for a relaxed cafe experience or in the evening on weekends for a more lively community bar atmosphere.
- Combine your visit with a walk around Balfour village, the harbour, or nearby historic sites to make the most of your time on Shapinsay.
- Be prepared for a small, intimate space with limited seating; it’s best suited to a casual, unhurried stop rather than a large group meal without prior arrangement.
For the on-the-go comforts that matter to you
- Restrooms
- Drink Options
- Drinking Water
- Food Options
- Seating Areas
- Trash Bins
The Smithy Cafe location weather suitability
-
Any Weather
-
Rain / Wet Weather
-
Mild Temperatures
Discover more about The Smithy Cafe
A Community Heart in a Historic Smithy
Nestled in the small Orkney island village of Balfour, The Smithy occupies a building that once echoed with the clang of hammer on anvil. Today, that same space hums with conversation, the clink of cups, and the aroma of freshly brewed coffee and home-style cooking. Run by the Shapinsay Development Trust, this cafe and restaurant is a true community project, reflecting the island’s spirit of self-reliance and hospitality. The interior retains a rustic charm, with exposed stone and timber, while modern touches make it comfortable for both locals dropping in for a mid-morning tea and visitors exploring the island.Simple, Local Fare with Orkney Flavour
The menu focuses on straightforward, satisfying food made with local ingredients where possible. Expect classic cafe staples like soups, sandwiches, and baked goods, alongside more substantial pub-style meals in the evening. The emphasis is on quality and comfort rather than fine dining, making it an ideal place to refuel after a walk along the coast or a visit to nearby historic sites. Drinks range from tea and coffee to local ales and spirits, served in a relaxed, unpretentious setting that feels more like a village hall than a commercial eatery.More Than Just a Cafe
Beyond its role as a cafe and restaurant, The Smithy often doubles as a community bar in the evenings, especially on weekends, adding a convivial social dimension. It’s a place where islanders gather, news is exchanged, and visitors are welcomed into the rhythm of island life. The space sometimes hosts local art, crafts, and events, reinforcing its role as a cultural and social hub. This dual function means the atmosphere can shift from a quiet daytime cafe to a lively evening spot, depending on the day and time.Practicalities for Visitors
Opening hours are limited and vary by season, typically running for a few hours each day from mid-morning to mid-afternoon, with extended evening service on certain days. Because of its remote island location and community-run nature, it’s essential to check current opening times before planning a visit, as they can change based on staffing and demand. The cafe is small and intimate, with limited seating, so it’s best suited to a relaxed, unhurried stop rather than a large group meal without prior arrangement. There’s no formal reservation system, but the staff are usually happy to accommodate if space allows.Atmosphere and Island Context
The Smithy’s charm lies in its authenticity. It’s not a tourist trap but a genuine part of Shapinsay’s daily life. The pace is slow, the service friendly, and the surroundings unpolished in the best possible way. Sitting here, you’re not just having a meal; you’re experiencing a slice of Orkney island culture, where community, history, and landscape are deeply intertwined. The nearby harbour, fields, and coastline provide a quiet, windswept backdrop that complements the cafe’s down-to-earth character.Planning Your Visit
Shapinsay is reached by a short ferry ride from Kirkwall on Mainland Orkney, and The Smithy is a natural focal point once on the island. It’s well placed for combining with walks to nearby sites like the Balfour Castle gardens, the standing stones, or the island’s scenic coastal paths. Because of the limited opening hours, it’s wise to plan your island itinerary around the cafe’s schedule, perhaps timing a visit for lunch or an afternoon break. The Smithy is a place to slow down, enjoy simple food, and soak in the unique atmosphere of a small Orkney community.Iconic landmarks you can’t miss
First Nations And Orcadian Totem Pole
15.2 km
A striking wooden monument in Orkney symbolizing friendship and shared heritage between First Nations and Orcadian cultures.
Churchill Barriers
15.5 km
Historic WWII causeways in Orkney that safeguarded Scapa Flow and now link islands with a rich legacy of resilience and culture.
The Cannon
24.0 km
Historic cannon from an American privateer, set against the stunning backdrop of Stromness harbour’s maritime heritage.
John O'Groats Signpost
44.2 km
Britain's most iconic signpost marks the legendary endpoint of the 874-mile Land's End to John o' Groats journey.
Duncansby Stacks
45.2 km
Discover the breathtaking Duncansby Stacks, a natural marvel of towering cliffs and vibrant wildlife on Scotland's stunning coastline.
The Castle & Gardens of Mey
46.5 km
Explore the Castle & Gardens of Mey, where Scottish history and breathtaking landscapes come together in a royal retreat.
North Ronaldsay
47.0 km
Explore North Ronaldsay: A remote Scottish island known for its stunning landscapes, unique wildlife, and rich cultural heritage, perfect for nature lovers and history buffs.
Dunnet Head Lighthouse
48.3 km
Experience the stunning beauty and rich heritage of Dunnet Head Lighthouse, Scotland's northernmost landmark with breathtaking coastal views.
Bucholie Castle
51.5 km
Discover the rich history and stunning views of Bucholie Castle, an enchanting historical landmark in Nybster, near Wick, Scotland.
Above and Beyond Tours
52.2 km
Discover the breathtaking landscapes of Caithness with Above and Beyond Tours, where adventure meets local expertise in Scotland's stunning north.
Mary Ann's Cottage
52.3 km
Explore the fascinating history of Caithness at Mary Ann's Cottage, a charming museum showcasing 19th-century life and culture.
Caithness Broch Centre
53.9 km
Explore the ancient Iron Age at the Caithness Broch Centre, a unique attraction that unveils the mysteries of Scotland's historic broch structures.
Nybster Broch
54.4 km
Discover the enchanting Nybster Broch, an ancient Iron Age site in Scotland offering a unique glimpse into Pictish history amidst stunning coastal vistas.
Dunnet Links: St. Coomb Chapel (6th century, former site))
55.5 km
Discover the ancient ruins of St. Coomb Chapel, a 6th-century site near Castletown that reveals Scotland’s early Christian heritage.
Castlehill Heritage Centre
55.6 km
Discover the captivating history and culture of Castletown at the Castlehill Heritage Centre, a unique museum in the heart of the Scottish Highlands.
Unmissable attractions to see
Orkney Wireless Museum
6.1 km
Explore a century of wireless communication and wartime heritage in Orkney’s volunteer-run museum with interactive exhibits and rare memorabilia.
The Orkney Distillery & Visitor Centre
6.1 km
Discover Orkney’s hand-crafted spirits and rich heritage at Kirkwall’s vibrant distillery and visitor centre on the historic harbour front.
Grain Earth House
6.2 km
Discover the enchanting Grain Earth House, a historical landmark in Kirkwall, Orkney, showcasing ancient architecture and rich cultural heritage.
Badly Drawn Cat
6.2 km
A cozy vegan café and art gallery in Kirkwall blending plant-based delights with local creativity and friendly charm.
St Magnus Cathedral
6.4 km
Explore Scotland’s oldest cathedral, a stunning medieval masterpiece and spiritual heart of Orkney, rich with Norse history and vibrant cultural life.
The Orkney Museum
6.4 km
Discover Orkney’s story from ancient times to today in the historic Tankerness House, home to nationally significant archaeology and vibrant cultural exhibits.
The Tankerness House
6.4 km
Explore Orkney’s rich history in the stunning 16th-century Tankerness House, home to the internationally significant Orkney Museum.
Bishop’s and Earl's Palaces
6.4 km
Explore Kirkwall’s medieval and Renaissance palaces where Norse kings and notorious earls shaped Orkney’s history.
Rendall Doocot
7.1 km
Explore Rendall Doocot, Orkney’s rare 17th-century beehive dovecote, a unique symbol of historic rural life and architectural ingenuity.
Burroughston Broch
7.6 km
Explore Burroughston Broch, an ancient Iron Age landmark on Shapinsay Island, Orkney, where history and natural beauty intertwine.
Highland Park Whisky Distillery
7.6 km
Explore the northernmost Scotch whisky distillery, blending Viking heritage and Orkney’s unique peat smoke into world-renowned single malts.
Wideford Hill Cairn
8.3 km
Explore Wideford Hill Cairn, a majestic 5,000-year-old Neolithic tomb in Orkney, blending ancient architecture with celestial mysteries and stunning views.
Wideford Hill Scenic View
8.3 km
A quiet Orkney hilltop with sweeping views over Kirkwall, the Bay of Firth, and the surrounding countryside, perfect for panoramic photos and peaceful reflection.
Scapa Beach
8.7 km
Discover the tranquil beauty and rich maritime history of Scapa Beach, a scenic coastal gem near Kirkwall in Orkney.
Rennibister Earth House
9.0 km
Discover the Rennibister Earth House, a prehistoric marvel nestled in the Orkney Islands, embodying ancient heritage and natural beauty.
Essential places to dine
The Smithy Cafe
0.0 km
A community-run cafe and restaurant in a historic smithy on Shapinsay, serving Orkney fare in a warm, rustic setting with occasional evening bar service.
The Shore
6.0 km
Modern waterfront hotel in Kirkwall's harbor district with clean rooms, full breakfast, and walking access to town attractions.
Dil Se Restaurant
6.0 km
Experience authentic North Indian and Bangladeshi flavors in Kirkwall’s award-winning Dil Se Restaurant, blending tradition with local freshness.
Helgi's
6.1 km
A vibrant harbourfront gastropub blending Orkney’s Viking heritage with fresh local fare and lively community spirit.
The Storehouse Restaurant with Rooms
6.1 km
A boutique dining and accommodation gem in Kirkwall blending historic charm with world-class local cuisine and cozy rooms.
Pomona Cafe
6.1 km
A cozy, traditional Kirkwall cafe serving hearty breakfasts and warm hospitality in the heart of Orkney’s capital.
Twenty One
6.1 km
A vibrant Kirkwall hotspot serving unique tapas and expertly crafted cocktails in a stylish, welcoming setting.
Trenabies Cafe Bistro
6.1 km
Cozy cafe and bistro in Kirkwall offering hearty local dishes, great coffee, and friendly service in a welcoming atmosphere.
Bothy Bar
6.1 km
Experience the warmth of Bothy Bar in Kirkwall – where delicious food meets delightful drinks in a cozy atmosphere.
Busters Diner
6.2 km
A cozy American-style diner in Kirkwall serving hearty comfort food with British influences and local Orkney beers in a relaxed setting.
Lucano
6.5 km
Experience authentic Italian flavors and warm hospitality in the heart of Kirkwall at Lucano, a beloved local restaurant and pizzeria.
The Orkney Hotel
6.5 km
Historic charm meets cosy comfort and local hospitality in the heart of Kirkwall at The Orkney Hotel.
Empire Chinese Restaurant
6.5 km
A reliable, family-friendly Chinese restaurant in central Kirkwall, serving generous portions of classic dishes in a relaxed setting.
Happy Haddock
6.6 km
Classic Orkney fish and chips with friendly service and hearty portions in the heart of Kirkwall.
Sakura Kitchen
6.9 km
Authentic Japanese takeaway in Kirkwall with weekly-changing menus and ceremonial matcha from Kyoto.
Markets, malls and hidden boutiques
Anchor Shopping Centre
6.0 km
A compact, modern shopping mall in central Kirkwall, offering everyday essentials, fashion, health and beauty, and practical services in a convenient indoor setting.
Orkney Souvenirs
6.0 km
Discover authentic Orkney crafts and local treasures in Kirkwall’s welcoming souvenir shop, celebrating island heritage and artistry.
The Orcadian Bookshop
6.1 km
Discover Orkney’s stories and culture at The Orcadian Bookshop, Kirkwall’s independent literary gem in the historic city centre.
Poundstretcher
6.2 km
Discover unbeatable value and variety at Poundstretcher Kirkwall, your go-to discount store in the heart of Orkney’s town center.
Kairds
6.2 km
Discover unique gifts and local crafts that capture the spirit of Orkney at Kairds, Kirkwall’s beloved gift shop on Albert Street.
Logo Orkney
6.2 km
Explore Logo Orkney for unique clothing and authentic Orkney-themed souvenirs, perfect for capturing your travel memories.
Starlings
6.3 km
Discover authentic Orcadian gifts and crafts at Starlings, a charming boutique shop in Kirkwall’s historic heart.
Aurora Jewellery
6.3 km
Discover exquisite hand-crafted jewellery inspired by Orkney’s heritage and landscapes at Aurora Jewellery in Kirkwall.
The Longship
6.3 km
Discover Orkney’s rich heritage through timeless jewellery, knitwear, and crafts at Kirkwall’s family-run Longship shop.
Judith Glue
6.4 km
Discover Kirkwall’s charming Aladdin’s Cave of local gifts, knitwear, and jewellery at Judith Glue, a beloved hub of Orcadian craftsmanship since 1976.
The Original Orkney Hamper Company
6.4 km
Discover authentic Orkney flavors and handcrafted gifts in charming hampers from Kirkwall’s beloved local shop.
Blue Joe's
6.5 km
Discover authentic Orkney crafts and unique souvenirs at Blue Joe's, Kirkwall’s charming gift shop full of local treasures and stories.
Orkney Tweed
6.5 km
Discover authentic Orkney tweed craftsmanship in Kirkwall’s charming boutique, where tradition meets sustainable artisan quality.
St Colms Cafe & Crafts
6.7 km
A cozy Kirkwall café and crafts shop offering homemade treats and unique handcrafted garden furniture and cards.
MadeitOrkney
13.8 km
Discover authentic Orcadian crafts and handmade treasures in the tranquil setting of Deerness, Orkney Mainland’s artisan hub.
Essential bars & hidden hideouts
Torvhaug
6.0 km
A lively Kirkwall pub on Bridge Street, Torvhaug offers local whiskys, cozy vibes, and a vibrant atmosphere beloved by locals and visitors alike.
Skippers
6.0 km
Kirkwall’s vibrant sports bar serving local brews, hearty pub fare, and live games in a welcoming, dog-friendly atmosphere.
Highland Park Bar
6.0 km
A cozy Kirkwall bar serving an extensive range of Highland Park whiskies and local drinks in a warm, inviting atmosphere within the Kirkwall Hotel.
Ayre Hotel & Apartments
6.1 km
Comfortable harbor-side hotel with a lively bar, friendly staff, and easy access to Kirkwall’s historic center.
The Neuk
6.1 km
A warm and lively pub-restaurant in Kirkwall offering fresh local fare, historic charm, and a vibrant live music scene.
Oot The Back
6.1 km
Discover Kirkwall’s cozy outdoor garden bar with heated booths, local gins, and a relaxed atmosphere behind Orkney Distilling.
Auld Motor Hoose
6.2 km
A cozy Kirkwall pub blending automotive nostalgia with friendly service and local ales in a lively, welcoming atmosphere.
Royal Cask Whisky Gin Bar
6.5 km
Discover Kirkwall’s historic Royal Cask Whisky Gin Bar, home to over 1,000 whiskies, 160 gins, and authentic Orcadian hospitality in a 350-year-old setting.
The West End Guest House
6.7 km
A peaceful, centrally located guest house in Kirkwall offering simple comforts and easy access to Orkney’s historic heart.
The Taversoe
13.1 km
A cozy 3-star inn on Rousay offering spacious rooms, local cuisine, and stunning sea views in a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Robertsons Coffeehoose & Bar
23.2 km
A warm, family-run coffeehouse and bar in historic St Margaret's Hope, serving traditional fare, local drinks, and inclusive menus in a charming setting.
The Belsair
28.3 km
A cozy gastropub and guesthouse on Sanday offering fresh local seafood, comfortable rooms, and authentic island hospitality.
The Mey Hotel
47.7 km
Experience warm Highland hospitality, hearty Scottish fare, and cozy comfort at The Mey Hotel in scenic Thurso.
Dunnet Bay Escapes
52.3 km
Luxurious coastal retreat with stunning Dunnet Bay views, gourmet breakfasts, and serene hot tub relaxation in the heart of the Scottish Highlands.
The Village Inn
56.7 km
A cozy Highland village pub offering hearty meals, real ales, and warm hospitality in the scenic community of Keiss.
Nightclubs & after hour spots
The Orkney Club
6.1 km
A welcoming social hub in Kirkwall offering lively evening entertainment and a friendly community atmosphere in the heart of Orkney.
Skinandi's Nightclub
60.2 km
Experience the vibrant nightlife at Skinandi's, the northernmost nightclub on Scotland’s mainland with two bars and two dance floors.
The Waterfront
66.4 km
Wick's vibrant nightlife heart with a lively dance floor, diverse music, and a welcoming atmosphere on the scenic Shore.
For the vibe & atmosphere seeker
- Relaxing
- Tranquil
- Scenic
- Casual
For the design and aesthetic lover
- Rustic Designs
- Vintage Styles
For the architecture buff
- Historic
- Heritage Neighborhoods
For the view chaser and sunset hunter
- Waterfront
For the social media creator & influencer
- Photo Spots
- Aesthetic Corners
For the eco-conscious traveler
- Community-Run
- Locally Managed
For the kind of experience you’re after
- Cultural Heritage
- Day Trip
For how adventurous you want the journey to be
- Easy Access
Location Audience
- Family Friendly
- Senior Friendly
- Child Friendly
- Teen Friendly
- Wheelchair Access
- Solo Friendly
- Couple Friendly
- Solo Female Friendly
- Vegetarian Friendly
