Kroll's West

The Butter Burger Legend

Kroll's West has earned its place on the Roadfood map as the home of Wisconsin's most celebrated butter burger. The magic lies in simplicity: a lunch-counter round of beef, cooked through and juicy, topped with a generous pat of butter that melts into the meat, creating an absolutely delectable bite. Each burger arrives wrapped in wax paper, dressed with ketchup, onions, and pickles on a crisp-crusted roll. The butter is the signature touch—a Wisconsin tradition that transforms an ordinary burger into something memorable. Bacon, lettuce, and tomato are available for additional cost, and the kitchen will even substitute margarine if requested, though locals consider this heretical in the Dairy State.

Beyond the Burger

While butter burgers are the main attraction, the menu offers substantial variety. The prime rib sandwich stands as a worthy alternative: shaved prime rib piled high in a toasted-crisp bun, tender and luxurious, combined with melting butter and au jus for dipping. Broasted chicken, battered perch, and Wisconsin cheese curds round out the offerings. The cheese curds deserve special mention—golden, crispy, and delicious, they pair perfectly with any entrée. The kitchen also serves peanut butter and jelly sandwiches and other comfort food classics.

Vintage Atmosphere and Game Day Culture

Located directly across from Lambeau Field, Kroll's West embodies Green Bay sports culture. The diner features colorful, rounded booths and classic mid-century Americana décor that transports diners back in time. On game days, the beer garden opens early for pre-game celebrations and post-game festivities, with green and yellow dominating the scene. The self-seating format and old-school call button on the wall add to the nostalgic charm. The western-style interior creates a cozy, welcoming vibe that appeals to both locals and visitors seeking authentic Wisconsin dining.

Service and Dining Experience

Kroll's West operates as a casual, counter-service establishment with booth seating. Diners seat themselves and use a wall button to summon service—a fun, old-school touch that reflects the restaurant's vintage character. The staff is generally friendly and accommodating. However, service consistency has been noted as variable, with some diners reporting slow refill service and inattentive staff during busy periods. The restaurant does not take reservations on weekends, though waits are typically manageable even during peak times. Weekday reservations are available for larger groups.

Pricing and Value

Kroll's West operates in the mid-range price category. Base burgers start around $7, with add-ons like bacon, lettuce, and tomato costing approximately $2 each. Sides such as French fries ($3.50) and cheese curds are additional charges. Coffee is priced at $3. While some diners feel the pricing is steep relative to portion sizes and quality consistency, others consider the iconic butter burger worth the investment. The restaurant accepts credit cards and serves alcohol, including beer and cocktails.

Hours and Accessibility

Kroll's West opens daily at 10:30 AM, with closing times varying by day: 9 PM Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Sunday; 10 PM Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday. The location is easily accessible from Lambeau Field and serves lunch, dinner, and late-night meals. The restaurant features outdoor seating options, making it suitable for various weather conditions and dining preferences.