The Pickled Herring, Madeline Island Travel Guide

4.4 (174)

Experience the best of Bayfield dining at The Pickled Herring, where fresh grilled specialties and local flavors come together in a cozy atmosphere.

Nestled in the charming town of Bayfield, Wisconsin, The Pickled Herring offers a delightful dining experience with a focus on grilled specialties and local ingredients. Tourists can enjoy a relaxed atmosphere while savoring delicious dishes that highlight the region's culinary traditions.

A brief summary to The Pickled Herring

1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, Wisconsin, 54814, US
Click to display

Tuesday 11 am-9:30 pm
Wednesday 11 am-9:30 pm
Thursday 11 am-9:30 pm
Friday 11 am-10 pm
Saturday 11 am-10 pm
Sunday 3 pm-8:30 pm

From Eve

Know before you go

Hi, I'm Eve. Here are a few practical things to know before exploring The Pickled Herring.

Try the daily specials for unique dishes made from fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.
Arrive early during peak season to secure a table, as it can get busy.
Don't forget to sample one of their craft beers or local wines to enhance your meal.
Check out the happy hour specials for great deals on drinks and appetizers.

Do you manage this location?

Take control to get all the benefits, like improved information, better appearance, and stronger visibility across AI-powered discovery. Learn more about listing your business on Evendo

Activate your presence

Other nearby places you may find interesting

The closest places of the same kind, if this one is not quite what you had in mind.

Pub Restaurant & Wine Bar

Tom's Burned Down Cafe

Beach Club on Madeline Island

Bell Street Tavern, Events, and Lodging

The Creamery Bar

Explore The Pickled Herring on the Map

A handpicked selection of must-see spots near The Pickled Herring, mapped for you.

Discover more about The Pickled Herring

The Pickled Herring is a must-visit destination for tourists seeking a unique dining experience in Bayfield, Wisconsin. Known for its friendly atmosphere and mouthwatering grilled dishes, this charming grill stands out as a local favorite. Guests can indulge in a menu that emphasizes fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, providing a true taste of the region. The restaurant's inviting interior features rustic decor, creating a warm and welcoming space for visitors to unwind after a day of exploration.The menu at The Pickled Herring features a variety of options, from delectable seafood dishes to hearty meat selections, ensuring that there is something for everyone. Don't miss out on their signature grilled specials, which showcase the chef's creativity and passion for flavor. Pair your meal with a selection from their impressive drink menu, featuring local beers and wines that complement the culinary offerings perfectly.Open for lunch and dinner, The Pickled Herring is the ideal spot to gather with friends or family. Whether you're stopping by after a day of hiking the stunning Apostle Islands or looking for a relaxing evening out, this grill promises a memorable dining experience filled with laughter and great food. Make sure to check their hours as they may vary throughout the week, ensuring you don't miss out on the chance to enjoy this delightful eatery.