Background

The Pickled Herring, Madeline Island Travel Guide

4.4 (174)

Experience culinary excellence at The Pickled Herring, where delicious grill dishes meet stunning Lake Superior views in Bayfield.

Nestled along the scenic shores of Lake Superior, The Pickled Herring offers a delightful grill experience in Bayfield, Wisconsin. With its vibrant atmosphere and mouth-watering menu, this restaurant is a must-visit for tourists seeking delicious local cuisine and stunning views.

A brief summary to The Pickled Herring

  • Tuesday 11 am-9:30 pm
  • Wednesday 11 am-9:30 pm
  • Thursday 11 am-9:30 pm
  • Friday 11 am-10 pm
  • Saturday 11 am-10 pm
  • Sunday 3 pm-8:30 pm
Eve
From Eve

Know before you go

Hi, I'm Eve. Here are a few practical things to know before exploring The Pickled Herring.

  • Try their daily specials for unique flavors inspired by local ingredients.
  • Visit during sunset hours for an unforgettable dining experience with spectacular lake views.
  • Make reservations on weekends to ensure you get a table at this popular spot.
  • Don’t forget to sample their dessert menu; it's highly praised by locals!

Do you manage this location?

Take control to get all the benefits, like improved information, better appearance, and stronger visibility across AI-powered discovery. Learn more about listing your business on Evendo

Activate your presence

Other nearby places you may find interesting

The closest places of the same kind, if this one is not quite what you had in mind.

Explore The Pickled Herring on the Map

A handpicked selection of must-see spots near The Pickled Herring, mapped for you.

Unlock the Best of The Pickled Herring

Buy tickets

  • No tickets available

Book tours with entry

  • No tours available

Book tours without entry

  • No tours available

Discover more about The Pickled Herring

The Pickled Herring is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience that captures the essence of Bayfield, Wisconsin. Located near the beautiful shores of Lake Superior, this grill serves up a menu rich in flavor and variety, showcasing the best of local ingredients. From fresh seafood to hearty meat dishes, every meal is crafted with care to ensure a memorable dining experience.As you step into The Pickled Herring, you’re greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere that perfectly complements the stunning views of the lake. The interior is designed with rustic charm, making it an ideal spot for both casual lunches and special dinners. Whether you're enjoying a sunny afternoon on the outdoor patio or cozying up inside during cooler months, the ambiance adds to your overall enjoyment.Don’t miss out on their signature dishes that highlight regional flavors; each bite tells a story of the area’s culinary heritage. Pair your meal with one of their carefully selected local wines or craft beers for an authentic taste of Wisconsin. With friendly service and a commitment to quality, The Pickled Herring stands out as a top destination for tourists looking to indulge in delightful cuisine while soaking in breathtaking lakeside views.
Mobile App

Your all‑in‑one travel companion app

Explore expert travel guides, compare and book tours, experiences, hotels, and more—all from the palm of your hand. Download now for seamless trip planning wherever your wanderlust takes you.



Explore More of Madeline Island

Looking beyond The Pickled Herring? Discover Madeline Island for broader travel guides, local hot-spots, and regional highlights.

Explore Madeline Island

Select Currency