Pie Whole Pizza, Peter Island Travel Guide

Name: Pie Whole Pizza
Address: 24a U.S. Virgin Islands, Honduras, Charlotte Amalie, 00802, VI
Telephone: +1340-642-5074
Price range: 2
Rating: 4.2

4.2 (419)

Casual Frenchtown pizzeria firing up wood-oven pizzas, pet-friendly patio vibes, and island hospitality in Charlotte Amalie—a local favorite for flavorful bites and breezy evenings.

Pie Whole Pizza in Charlotte Amalie's Frenchtown serves wood-fired pizzas, wings, pasta, and salads in a lively outdoor patio setting. Known for its casual vibe, pet-friendly atmosphere, and accommodating staff, it draws locals and visitors alike. Open daily from noon to 9 PM with moderate prices and a 4.2-star rating from hundreds of reviews.

A brief summary to Pie Whole Pizza

24a U.S. Virgin Islands, Honduras, Charlotte Amalie, St Thomas, 00802, VI
Click to display
Click to display
Duration: 0.5 to 2 hours
Mid ranged
Outdoor
Mobile reception: 5 out of 5

Tuesday 12 pm-9 pm
Wednesday 12 pm-9 pm
Thursday 12 pm-9 pm
Friday 12 pm-9 pm
Saturday 12 pm-9 pm
Sunday 12 pm-9 pm

From Eve

Know before you go

Hi, I'm Eve. Here are a few practical things to know before exploring Pie Whole Pizza.

Call ahead for gluten-free options or large groups, as they accommodate dietary needs but stock can vary.
Opt for outdoor patio seating to enjoy the Frenchtown scene with pets welcome.
Arrive early for peak dinner hours to avoid waits in this small, popular spot.

Do you manage this location?

Take control to get all the benefits, like improved information, better appearance, and stronger visibility across AI-powered discovery. Learn more about listing your business on Evendo

Activate your presence

Other nearby places you may find interesting

The closest places of the same kind, if this one is not quite what you had in mind.

Oceans 7 Yacht Club

Pirates Bight

D'CoalPot BVI Restaurant Bar & Grill

Bamboushay Restaurant & Lounge

Loose Mongoose

Explore Pie Whole Pizza on the Map

A handpicked selection of must-see spots near Pie Whole Pizza, mapped for you.

Getting There

Walking

10-15 min stroll from Charlotte Amalie cruise port through Frenchtown; free, scenic waterfront path.
Taxi

$8-12 one-way from downtown; 5 min ride, available 24/7 but negotiate fare.
Driving

5 min drive via Veterans Drive; free street parking nearby, watch for narrow roads.

For the on-the-go comforts that matter to you

Drink Options
Food Options
Seating Areas

Discover more about Pie Whole Pizza

Overview

Nestled in the heart of Frenchtown, Charlotte Amalie, Pie Whole Pizza stands out as a beloved casual eatery specializing in New York-style and wood-fired pizzas. Located at 24A Honduras, this spot captures the vibrant spirit of St. Thomas with its outdoor patio seating overlooking the neighborhood's colorful charm. Moderate pricing makes it accessible for families, couples, and solo diners seeking authentic island pizza experiences.

Menu Highlights

The menu features classic pizzas like pepperoni, vegetarian, and specialty options, alongside wings, zeppole, chicken parmesan, Caesar salads, and gluten-free pasta alternatives. Diners praise the delicious veggie pizzas and generous toppings, though some note variability in delivery quality. The bar offers selections including Tito's vodka, enhancing the relaxed hangout feel. Portions suit sharing, with prices reflecting the tropical locale.

Atmosphere and Service

This pet-friendly venue buzzes with a homey, cooperative staff dynamic where servers engage guests like family. Outdoor seating accommodates dogs and groups, fostering a fun, local scene amid Frenchtown's artistic vibe. While some report service delays or kitchen mix-ups, many highlight friendly, accommodating teams that handle dietary needs like gluten-free or dairy-free requests.

Practical Details

Operating from 12 PM to 9 PM daily except Mondays, it's ideal for lunch or dinner. Call ahead for peak times or special orders, as it's a small, popular spot. Ample outdoor space provides a breezy Caribbean dining escape, perfect for watching the neighborhood unfold.

Why Visit

Pie Whole Pizza embodies St. Thomas' casual dining soul—unpretentious, flavorful, and community-oriented. Whether grabbing a slice to-go or lingering on the patio, it delivers satisfying meals in a quintessential Frenchtown setting.