Banana Split Sweet & Savory

Discovering the Delights

Tucked away on Raadets Gade in the heart of Charlotte Amalie, Banana Split Sweet & Savory beckons with its irresistible aroma of fresh-baked goods wafting through the tropical air. This petite eatery specializes in an enticing blend of sweet confections and hearty savory fare, all meticulously handmade by owner Sarah. From flaky hand pies stuffed with chicken, onions, and cheese to tender lamb kebobs wrapped in warm flatbread, every item bursts with authentic flavors influenced by American, Lebanese, and Mediterranean cuisines. The shop's ice cream counter shines with homemade scoops in flavors like dulce de leche, served in waffle or sugar cones, or piled high into the namesake banana split topped with your choice of indulgent extras.

Savory Sensations and Sweet Escapes

Lunchtime transforms this spot into a savory haven. Diners rave about the pot pies, shepherd's pies, and falafel wraps, paired perfectly with daily specials like velvety pumpkin soup or hummus sides. Savory options extend to sausage, pepper, and onion pies or mushroom, onion, potato, and gouda fillings, all encased in light, airy crusts that melt in your mouth. For those seeking refreshment amid St. Thomas's heat, the ice cream selection provides cool relief—milkshakes, rich coffee drinks, and tarts round out a menu designed for quick bites or leisurely indulgences. The air-conditioned interior offers a comfortable respite, ideal after exploring nearby historic sites like Emancipation Garden or the 99 Steps.

A Personal Touch from Sarah

Sarah's passion infuses every creation, from breads and pies to unique kabobs. Her warm hospitality elevates the experience, making visitors feel like family. Open daily from 9am to 5pm, the shop caters to breakfast crowds with pastries and evolves into a lunch hotspot. It's available for private events, blending convenience with quality in Charlotte Amalie's vibrant shopping district. Proximity to waterfront buses and walking paths from Main Street ensures easy access for tourists wandering the US Virgin Islands' capital.

Perfect Pit Stop in Paradise

Whether grabbing a hand pie for the road or savoring a baklava and ice cream combo, Banana Split delivers consistent excellence. Its location near landmarks like Fort Christian and Market Square positions it as an essential stop for food lovers seeking authentic, from-scratch eats amid island adventures. Affordable pricing keeps it accessible, proving that the best flavors often hide on quiet side streets.