A Culinary Haven in Nantucket: Brotherhood of Thieves
Experience the best of Nantucket's culinary scene at Brotherhood of Thieves, where delicious American grill fare meets a cozy atmosphere.
Nestled in the heart of Nantucket, the Brotherhood of Thieves offers a delightful blend of American grill classics and a cozy bar atmosphere. With a charm that reflects the island's rich maritime history, this popular eatery is perfect for both locals and tourists seeking a memorable dining experience. Enjoy a diverse menu featuring fresh seafood, hearty burgers, and an extensive selection of craft beers, all served in an inviting setting that captures the essence of coastal living.
A brief summary to Brotherhood of Thieves
- 23 Broad St, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554, US
- +1774-325-5812
- Visit website
- Monday 11:30 am-12 am
- Tuesday 11:30 am-12 am
- Wednesday 11:30 am-12 am
- Thursday 11:30 am-12 am
- Friday 11:30 am-12 am
- Saturday 11:30 am-12 am
- Sunday 11:30 am-12 am
Local tips
- Try to arrive early or make a reservation to avoid long wait times, especially during peak season.
- Don't miss their happy hour specials for discounted drinks and appetizers.
- Ask the staff for daily specials, as they often feature fresh, local seafood.
- Enjoy the outdoor seating area for a relaxing dining experience during the warmer months.
Discover more about Brotherhood of Thieves
Iconic landmarks you can’t miss
Nantucket Bookworks
0.0 km
Explore Nantucket Bookworks, a beloved bookstore and gift shop offering a unique selection of books, local literature, and artisanal gifts in a cozy setting.
Jared Coffin House
0.1 km
Discover the historic Jared Coffin House, a charming hotel in Nantucket offering modern comforts amidst classic elegance and a prime location for exploring the island.
Greydon House
0.1 km
Experience the charm of Nantucket at Greydon House, where historic elegance meets modern comfort for an unforgettable getaway.
Nantucket Information Bureau
0.1 km
Discover Nantucket's hidden treasures and plan your perfect island getaway at the Nantucket Information Bureau.
Nantucket Historical Association
0.1 km
Explore the rich maritime heritage of Nantucket at the Nantucket Historical Association, home to captivating exhibits and the iconic Whaling Museum.
Brass Lantern Inn
0.1 km
Discover the cozy elegance of Brass Lantern Inn, a charming bed & breakfast in Nantucket, perfect for your next coastal getaway.
Sunken Ship
0.1 km
Discover unique gifts and local treasures at the Sunken Ship in Nantucket, where every purchase tells a story of the island's rich heritage.
Sister Ship
0.1 km
Experience the flavors of the Mediterranean at Sister Ship, Nantucket's premier dining destination for exquisite cuisine and a delightful atmosphere.
The Mariner House
0.1 km
Discover the charm of Nantucket while staying at The Mariner House, a cozy apartment complex blending modern comforts with coastal beauty.
The Chapman House
0.2 km
Experience the charm of Nantucket at The Chapman House, a cozy bed & breakfast blending comfort and local heritage in a scenic waterfront setting.
Congregation Shirat HaYam
0.2 km
Explore Congregation Shirat HaYam, a serene synagogue in Nantucket, showcasing the island’s rich Jewish heritage and community spirit.
Dreamland Film, Theatre & Cultural Center
0.2 km
Discover the enchanting Dreamland Film, Theatre & Cultural Center in Nantucket, a perfect blend of cinematic magic and performing arts for all visitors.
Freedman's of Nantucket
0.2 km
Explore Freedman's of Nantucket for unique home decor, jewelry, and timepieces that embody the island's charm and craftsmanship.
Nantucket Preservation Trust
0.2 km
Explore the rich history and culture of Nantucket at the Nantucket Preservation Trust, where heritage meets community in a charming island setting.
29 India House
0.2 km
Experience cozy charm and warm hospitality at 29 India House, the perfect bed & breakfast for your Nantucket adventure.
Unmissable attractions to see
Whaling Museum
0.1 km
Discover Nantucket's maritime heritage at the Whaling Museum, a captivating journey through the island's whaling history and culture.
Nantucket Whaling Museum
0.1 km
Explore Nantucket's maritime heritage at the Whaling Museum, where history, culture, and stunning exhibits await every visitor.
Nantucket Atheneum
0.2 km
Discover the Nantucket Atheneum, a historic library that enriches your visit with literature, art, and cultural events on this charming island.
Nantucket Downtown Historic District
0.2 km
Discover Nantucket Downtown Historic District, a perfect blend of history, culture, and vibrant local life in Massachusetts.
Gardiner's Corner City Sign
0.3 km
Explore the iconic Gardiner's Corner City Sign in Nantucket, a charming symbol of history and culture perfect for capturing memorable moments.
Children's Beach Playground
0.3 km
Experience the joy of family fun at Children's Beach Playground, a safe and scenic haven in Nantucket, perfect for kids and parents alike.
Quaker Meeting House
0.3 km
Experience the serene beauty and rich history of Nantucket at the Quaker Meeting House, a peaceful tourist attraction and museum.
Waterfront Nantucket Harbor
0.4 km
Experience the tranquility and beauty of Waterfront Nantucket Harbor, a picturesque park perfect for relaxation and exploration amidst stunning coastal views.
Hadwen House
0.5 km
Explore the Hadwen House, a historical landmark in Nantucket that showcases the island's maritime history and architectural beauty.
Greater Light
0.5 km
Explore the enchanting Greater Light museum in Nantucket, where art meets history in a charming New England setting.
Maria Mitchell Aquarium
0.6 km
Explore the vibrant marine life at Maria Mitchell Aquarium in Nantucket, a captivating destination for education and conservation enthusiasts.
Jethro Coffin House
0.6 km
Explore the Jethro Coffin House, the oldest house in Nantucket, and delve into the island's rich colonial history and maritime heritage.
Historic Mitchell House
0.6 km
Discover the Historic Mitchell House in Nantucket, a museum dedicated to Maria Mitchell, America's first female astronomer, and her groundbreaking contributions.
Maria Mitchell Hinchman House Natural Science Museum
0.6 km
Discover the natural beauty and scientific wonders of Nantucket at Maria Mitchell Hinchman House Natural Science Museum, a must-visit for nature lovers.
Old Gaol
0.7 km
Unearth the captivating history of Nantucket at the Old Gaol, a unique historical landmark that narrates the island's rich past.
Essential places to dine
Brotherhood of Thieves
0.0 km
Experience delicious American cuisine at Brotherhood of Thieves in Nantucket—where every meal is a delightful adventure!
Dune
0.0 km
Discover Dune in Nantucket – an exquisite American restaurant offering seasonal dishes crafted from fresh local ingredients.
Le Languedoc Bistro
0.0 km
Savor exquisite French cuisine at Le Languedoc Bistro on Nantucket Island—where every meal is an unforgettable culinary journey.
Via Mare
0.1 km
Experience authentic Venetian cuisine at Via Mare in Nantucket - where every small plate tells a story of Italy's rich culinary heritage.
Nantucket Tap Room
0.1 km
Experience delightful American cuisine and vibrant nightlife at Nantucket Tap Room - where every meal is an adventure in flavor.
Ventuno Restaurant
0.1 km
Experience the essence of Italy at Ventuno Restaurant in Nantucket—where authentic flavors meet coastal charm.
Town
0.1 km
Experience exquisite dining at Town in Nantucket - where fresh seafood meets eclectic flavors in a charming coastal setting.
The Proprietors Bar & Table
0.1 km
Experience the best of American cuisine at The Proprietors Bar & Table in Nantucket - where local flavors meet vibrant atmosphere.
The Pearl
0.1 km
Discover the exquisite flavors of Asia at The Pearl in Nantucket - where fresh ingredients meet culinary artistry.
The Boarding House
0.1 km
Discover exquisite American cuisine at The Boarding House in Nantucket - where vibrant flavors meet charming ambiance.
Queequeg's
0.1 km
Experience the vibrant flavors of New American cuisine at Queequeg's in Nantucket - where every dish tells a story.
The Rose and Crown
0.1 km
Experience the best of American cuisine at The Rose and Crown – a family-friendly restaurant that transforms into a lively night club in Nantucket.
Company of the Cauldron
0.1 km
Discover exceptional American cuisine at Company of the Cauldron in Nantucket – where every dish tells a story.
Oran Mor
0.1 km
Experience exquisite New American cuisine at Oran Mor in Nantucket, where seasonal flavors meet coastal charm for an unforgettable dining experience.
Black-Eyed Susan's
0.2 km
Experience Nantucket’s culinary charm at Black-Eyed Susan’s with fresh New American dishes in a cozy setting.
Markets, malls and hidden boutiques
gypsy
0.1 km
Explore Gypsy Clothing Store in Nantucket for unique fashion that captures the essence of the island's culture and style.
Alice Walk - Nantucket Store
0.1 km
Shop at Alice Walk in Nantucket for unique women's clothing that blends local charm with contemporary style, making your trip unforgettable.
Atlantic Nantucket
0.1 km
Explore Atlantic Nantucket for unique clothing, antiques, and home goods, capturing the island's charm in every exquisite piece.
Antiques Depot
0.1 km
Explore the charm of Nantucket Antiques Depot, where history meets unique collectibles and vintage treasures await every visitor.
Eye Of The Needle
0.1 km
Explore Eye Of The Needle in Nantucket for unique, coastal-inspired fashion that embodies the island's charm and elegance.
John Rugge Antiques Shop
0.1 km
Uncover unique historical treasures at John Rugge Antiques Shop, a must-visit destination for antique enthusiasts in Nantucket.
Olivela
0.1 km
Explore Olivela, Nantucket's premier boutique offering a curated selection of luxury fashion and accessories for the discerning traveler.
Cattivo Nantucket
0.2 km
Discover the latest women's fashion trends at Cattivo Nantucket, where style meets the charm of island living.
Commonwealth
0.2 km
Explore the charm of Nantucket at Commonwealth, a delightful consignment shop brimming with unique treasures and vintage finds.
Lockhart Collection
0.2 km
Discover the charm of Nantucket at the Lockhart Collection, where antique furniture, unique jewelry, and exquisite lighting await.
Nalu
0.2 km
Explore Nalu, a charming clothing store in Nantucket, offering unique apparel and accessories that capture the essence of island life.
Andersons
0.2 km
Explore Andersons Gift Shop in Nantucket for unique souvenirs and local crafts that capture the island's enchanting spirit.
WHEAT Nantucket
0.2 km
Explore WHEAT Nantucket, a charming boutique offering upscale gifts and unique finds that capture the essence of coastal living.
Stephanie's
0.3 km
Discover unique gifts and boutique clothing at Stephanie's, a charming shop in Nantucket that captures the island's spirit.
current vintage
0.3 km
Explore Current Vintage in Nantucket for a unique blend of fine wines, vintage clothing, and eclectic antiques in a charming boutique setting.
Essential bars & hidden hideouts
Ethos Wine Bar & Bistro
0.0 km
Experience the best of Nantucket dining at Ethos Wine Bar & Bistro, where exquisite wines and bistro cuisine create unforgettable moments.
The Tree Bar
0.1 km
Experience the charm of Nantucket at The Tree Bar, where delicious food and craft cocktails meet a cozy, inviting atmosphere.
The Gaslight
0.2 km
Experience the vibrant flavors and delightful atmosphere at The Gaslight, a premier dining destination in Nantucket, Massachusetts.
The Chicken Box
1.6 km
Experience Nantucket's vibrant nightlife at The Chicken Box, a must-visit bar and nightclub offering great drinks and lively atmosphere.
The Muse
2.0 km
Discover The Muse, a vibrant bar in Nantucket offering an extensive drink menu and a lively atmosphere perfect for socializing and entertainment.
Roxy Pool Bar
36.0 km
Discover the laid-back charm of Roxy Pool Bar in Edgartown, where relaxation meets vibrant coastal vibes and unforgettable evenings.
Pelican Club
36.2 km
Discover the exquisite fusion of cocktails and sushi at Pelican Club, a must-visit bar and Japanese restaurant in Edgartown, Massachusetts.
The Newes From America
36.3 km
Discover The Newes From America, a charming bar in Edgartown offering a delightful blend of American cuisine and vibrant atmosphere perfect for tourists.
Brick Cellar Bar
36.9 km
Experience the cozy ambiance and gourmet delights at Brick Cellar Bar in Edgartown, a perfect spot for burgers and fine wine.
Town Bar and Grill MV
37.4 km
Experience the lively atmosphere and diverse menu at Town Bar and Grill MV, where great food meets unforgettable moments in Edgartown.
Bad Martha Farmers Brewery
37.7 km
Discover the vibrant craft beer scene at Bad Martha Farmers Brewery in Edgartown, Massachusetts, where local flavors come to life.
Ocean House Beach Bar
41.2 km
Enjoy creative cocktails and a vibrant beachside atmosphere at Ocean House Beach Bar in Dennis Port, Massachusetts.
Cleat & Anchor
41.5 km
Discover delicious grill specialties and refreshing drinks at Cleat & Anchor, the perfect coastal dining experience in Dennis Port, Massachusetts.
Captain Parker's Pub
41.8 km
Discover the authentic taste of New England at Captain Parker's Pub, where seafood delights meet a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Twenty Eight Club
42.4 km
Discover the lively atmosphere of Twenty Eight Club in Dennis Port, MA – where great food, drinks, and friendly locals create unforgettable memories.
