Destination guide
More about Fire Island
Discover Fire Island: A tranquil retreat with pristine beaches, charming hamlets, and vibrant culture just a ferry ride away from New York City.
Tell me more about Fire Island
Fire Island · Best Restaurants · Curated · Updated 2026
Best Restaurants in Fire Island
Discover the best restaurants in Fire Island. Find inspiration for your trip with our curated list of top-rated spots, local favorites, and hidden gems.
The 10 best restaurants in Fire Island
Fire Island Beach House
Experience coastal bliss at Fire Island Beach House - where relaxation meets vibrant beach life in Ocean Bay Park.
25 Cayuga St, Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770
Pizza Shack of Kismet
Experience the best New York-style pizza at Pizza Shack of Kismet on Fire Island - where delicious food meets stunning waterfront views.
Bay Walk &, Oak St, Fire Island, NY 11706
Pines Bistro
Discover the charm and flavors of Fire Island at Pines Bistro – your go-to destination for exquisite dining experiences.
36 Fire Island Blvd, Sayville, NY 11782
More to explore in Fire Island
Jump into the most useful discovery pages nearby, from experiences and heritage highlights to food, stays, shopping, and evening ideas.
Get the app
Your all‑in‑one travel companion app
Explore expert travel guides, compare and book tours, experiences, hotels, and more—all from the palm of your hand. Download now for seamless trip planning wherever your wanderlust takes you.