Best Shops in Fire Island
Discover the best shops in Fire Island. Find inspiration for your trip with our curated list of top-rated spots, local favorites, and hidden gems.
- Home
- New York
- Fire Island
- Best Shops in Fire Island
The 10 best shops in Fire Island
-
RACHEL’S Restaurant & Bakery
Experience the best of American cuisine and freshly baked goods at Rachel's Restaurant & Bakery in Ocean Beach, NY.
325 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117704.3Very Good 200 Reviews -
Seaview Market
Discover fresh produce and local delights at Seaview Market, your go-to grocery store in Ocean Beach, New York.
20 Duneway Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 117704.7Excellent 112 Reviews -
Davis Park Harbor store
Experience the local charm at Davis Park Harbor Store, your go-to spot for groceries, ice cream, and unique finds in Davis Park.
5 Trustees Walk, Patchogue, NY 117724.4Very Good 33 Reviews -
THE GALLERY Ocean Beach General Store
Explore the eclectic offerings of THE GALLERY Ocean Beach General Store, where unique gifts and local charm meet in a delightful shopping experience.
153 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117704.8Excellent 11 Reviews -
Pines Pantry
Explore the flavors of Fire Island at Pines Pantry, your go-to grocery store for local produce, baked goods, and artisanal delights.
57 Picketty Ruff Walk, Fire Island Pines, NY 117824.7Excellent 71 Reviews -
Kismet Coffee Company - Fire Island
Discover the cozy charm of Kismet Coffee Company on Fire Island, where exceptional brews and delightful pastries await you.
21 E Lighthouse Walk, Kismet, NY 117065.0Excellent 12 Reviews -
Ocean Bay Park Market
Explore Ocean Bay Park Market: Your gateway to fresh produce, local delicacies, and a taste of community life in Ocean Bay Park.
2 Cayuga St, Ocean Bay Park, NY 117704.0Very Good 29 Reviews -
Sweet Licks
Experience the joy of frozen treats at Sweet Licks, Cherry Grove's premier ice cream shop, perfect for families and friends to savor unique flavors and classic favorites.
181 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 117824.0Very Good 24 Reviews -
Kline's
Explore Kline's in Ocean Beach for unique beach-themed gifts and souvenirs that capture the essence of coastal living.
317 Bay Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 117704.8Excellent 9 Reviews -
Beaches & Cream
Experience the ultimate ice cream destination in Ocean Beach, NY, with unique flavors and delightful sundaes at Beaches & Cream.
479 Bay Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 117704.7Excellent 7 Reviews
More shops in Fire Island
-
FIG
Discover unique fashion and local treasures at FIG in Cherry Grove, a must-visit clothing store on Fire Island.
160 Main Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 117825.0Excellent 2 Reviews -
Bambootique
Discover the charm of Bambootique in Ocean Beach, NY – a boutique that offers stylish clothing and unique accessories reflecting beach life.
318 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117704.6Excellent 19 Reviews -
Scoops
Experience the ultimate ice cream paradise at Scoops in Ocean Beach, where every scoop is a delightful treat to savor.
310 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117704.2Very Good 32 Reviews -
Ice Castle
Experience the joy of delicious ice cream at the Ice Castle in Ocean Beach, NY, where every scoop is a sweet treat waiting for you.
319 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117703.6Good 17 Reviews -
The Pines Liquor Shop
Experience the charm of Fire Island Pines at The Pines Liquor Shop, your go-to destination for fine wines and a vibrant social scene.
57 Picketty Ruff Walk, Fire Island Pines, NY 117824.6Excellent 35 Reviews -
The Pantry
Explore The Pantry in Ocean Beach for fresh, local groceries and a friendly shopping experience by the shore.
1 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117703.9Good 12 Reviews -
FiveEightThree
Explore FiveEightThree in Ocean Beach for trendy clothing and accessories that capture the essence of beach fashion and local style.
318 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117705.0Excellent 2 Reviews -
Grove Market
Discover the charm of Grove Market in Cherry Grove, a community grocery store offering fresh local produce and artisanal delights on Fire Island.
Main Walk, Fire Island, NY 117824.7Excellent 14 Reviews -
TOLA.
Explore TOLA, a chic clothing store in Fire Island Pines offering trendy apparel and accessories for your beachside getaway.
Harbor Walk, Fire Island Pines, NY 117825.0Excellent 5 Reviews -
Fire Island Liquor Store
Experience the vibrant selection of wines and spirits at Fire Island Liquor Store, the perfect stop for beachgoers in Ocean Beach, NY.
154 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117703.5Good 6 Reviews -
General Store by BASE
Discover unique treasures at the General Store by BASE, a boutique in Fire Island Pines offering local goods and beach essentials in a charming setting.
49 Harbor Walk, Sayville, NY 117824.5Excellent 4 Reviews -
Salty Stitch Beach Wear
Explore Salty Stitch Beach Wear in Ocean Beach, NY for stylish swimwear and beach accessories, perfect for creating unforgettable summer memories.
633 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117705.0Excellent 3 Reviews -
On a Whim Gift Store
Explore the charm of On a Whim Gift Store in East Islip, your go-to destination for unique gifts and local artisan treasures.
63 W Main St, East Islip, NY 117305.0Excellent 7 Reviews -
Ocean Beach Hardware
Discover the charm of Ocean Beach Hardware, your local stop for beach essentials and home improvement supplies in Ocean Beach, NY.
482 Bayberry Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117704.3Very Good 16 Reviews -
A Summer Place
Explore A Summer Place, a boutique in Ocean Beach offering an eclectic mix of fashion and local artistry that captures the essence of coastal style.
317 Bay Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 117705.0Excellent 2 Reviews -
Flair House
Experience the artistic flair of Ocean Beach at Flair House, a boutique offering unique local crafts and fashion in a charming setting.
472 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 117704.0Very Good 2 Reviews -
DENIZEN Fire Island
Explore the unique offerings at DENIZEN Fire Island, where local charm meets quality goods in the heart of Fire Island Pines.
108 Scaup Walk, Fire Island Pines, NY 117825.0Excellent 1 Reviews -
OBP Liquors
Explore OBP Liquors in Ocean Beach for a delightful selection of local wines, spirits, and craft beers, perfect for your seaside adventures.
1 Cayuga St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
Red Wagon Emporium
Explore the Red Wagon Emporium, your one-stop-shop for beach fun and essentials in Bay Shore, New York – a must-visit for families and beach lovers!
1 Bay Walk, Bay Shore, NY 11706 -
Hanalei and Kula's
Explore the unique charm of Hanalei and Kula's Gift Shop in Ocean Beach, where every treasure tells a story and every visit is a delightful experience.
472 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
More about Fire Island
Discover Fire Island: A tranquil retreat with pristine beaches, charming hamlets, and vibrant culture just a ferry ride away from New York City.
Tell me more about Fire IslandGet the latest from Evendo
Don't miss out on news and great deals