Rum Cay · Restaurants · Curated · Updated 2026

Restaurants in Rum Cay

Discover the best restaurants in Rum Cay. Find inspiration for your trip with our curated list of top-rated spots, local favorites, and hidden gems.

Audience 0

Audience

Experience 0

Experience

Practical 0

Practical

Weather 0

Weather

Accessibility 0

Accessibility

User rated 0

User rated

Sort byFeatured order
Audience 0

Audience

Experience 0

Experience

Practical 0

Practical

Weather 0

Weather

Accessibility 0

Accessibility

User rated 0

User rated

Sort byFeatured order
No results match these filters. Try adjusting your selection.
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/jimmy-buffett-s-margaritaville-bahamas

Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville Bahamas

Experience island life at Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville Bahamas with delicious American cuisine and stunning waterfront views.

2 Marina Drive Paradise Island N.P
3.8 Good 2,082 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/poop-deck

Poop Deck

Experience fresh seafood delights at Poop Deck in Nassau - where exquisite flavors meet breathtaking ocean views.

3MFJ+QWP, E Bay St, Nassau
4.2 Very Good 1,202 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/fish-by-jose-andres

Fish by José Andrés

Experience exquisite seafood dining at Fish by José Andrés on Paradise Island, where culinary artistry meets stunning ocean views.

Paradise Beach Dr. Suite 15 Paradise Island N.P
3.8 Good 524 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/nippers-beach-bar-grill

Nippers Beach Bar & Grill

Experience authentic Caribbean flavors at Nippers Beach Bar & Grill with stunning ocean views and lively atmosphere perfect for relaxation.

MV9R+6CP, Great Guana Cay
4.5 Excellent 458 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/goldie-s-conch-house

Goldie’s Conch House

Experience authentic Bahamian seafood at Goldie’s Conch House in Nassau – home to delicious conch fritters and vibrant island culture.

Arawak Cay Dr, Nassau
3.9 Good 604 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/the-swimming-pig-gastropub

The Swimming Pig Gastropub

Discover The Swimming Pig Gastropub in Nassau: where Bahamian flavors meet global cuisine in a vibrant setting perfect for any occasion.

1 Baha Mar Blvd, Nassau
3.9 Good 596 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/mckenzie-s-fresh-fish-conch

Mckenzie's Fresh Fish & Conch

Experience fresh seafood delights at McKenzie's Fresh Fish & Conch on Paradise Island - A true taste of Bahamian culinary heritage.

3MGH+643, The Dock,Paradise Island, Bridge
4.4 Very Good 601 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/carmine-s

Carmine's

Experience authentic Italian cuisine at Carmine's on Paradise Island - where every meal feels like a celebration.

One Casino Drive Suite 2, Paradise Island
3.8 Good 650 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/the-poop-deck-at-sandyport

The Poop Deck at Sandyport

Experience authentic Bahamian seafood at The Poop Deck at Sandyport with stunning views and lively atmosphere.

W Bay St, Nassau
4 Very Good 424 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/grabbers-bed-bar-and-grill

Grabbers Bed Bar and Grill

Experience Caribbean dining at its finest at Grabbers Bed Bar and Grill on Great Guana Cay—delicious food, stunning views, and vibrant atmosphere await!

MV8P+HPW, Great Guana Cay
4.4 Very Good 308 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/pink-octopus

Pink Octopus

Discover Bahamian flavors at Pink Octopus – where exquisite cuisine meets breathtaking views in Nassau.

Yamacraw Hill Rd, Nassau
4.1 Very Good 248 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/cafe-martinique

Café Martinique

Experience exquisite French cuisine at Café Martinique on Paradise Island – where elegance meets culinary artistry in the Bahamas.

One Casino Drive Suite 4, Paradise Island
4.2 Very Good 271 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/lukka-kairi-waterfront-bar-grill

Lukka Kairi Waterfront Bar & Grill

Discover culinary delights at Lukka Kairi Waterfront Bar & Grill with breathtaking views and authentic Bahamian flavors.

Woodes Rodgers Walk, Nassau
4.5 Excellent 114 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/murray-s-deli

Murray's Deli

Discover the flavors of Paradise Island at Murray's Deli, where fresh ingredients meet friendly service in a casual dining atmosphere.

One Casino Drive, Suite 28, Paradise Island
3.9 Good 459 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/pineapple-bar-and-grill

Pineapple Bar and Grill

Experience authentic Bahamian flavors at Pineapple Bar and Grill, where fresh seafood meets tropical vibes in a vibrant setting.

Brooklyn Rd
4.7 Excellent 144 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/the-beach-club

The Beach Club

Experience culinary bliss at The Beach Club in Bullock Harbour, where local flavors meet breathtaking ocean views.

P5V4+6MH, Bullock Harbour
4.4 Very Good 95 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/macduffs

MacDuffs

Experience the best of Bahamian cuisine at MacDuffs on Norman's Cay - where flavor meets hospitality in a stunning tropical setting.

Norman's Cay
4.4 Very Good 132 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/crabs-n-tings

Crabs-n-Tings

Experience authentic Bahamian cuisine at Crabs-n-Tings—where fresh seafood meets warm hospitality in Nassau.

3JHX+GR4, Nassau
4.6 Excellent 133 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/wild-orchids-waterfront-restaurant

Wild Orchids Waterfront Restaurant

Discover exquisite dining at Wild Orchids Waterfront Restaurant in Rock Sound, Bahamas - where local flavors meet stunning ocean views.

William street, Rock Sound
4.6 Excellent 99 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/emerald-sunset-view

Emerald Sunset View

Discover culinary delights and breathtaking sunsets at Emerald Sunset View in Great Guana Cay - your tropical dining escape.

Great Guana Cay Blackpoint Black point exuma cays
4.6 Excellent 115 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/the-bush-garden-seafood-steakhouse

The Bush Garden Seafood & Steakhouse

Experience fresh seafood and succulent steaks at The Bush Garden Seafood & Steakhouse in Nassau - a culinary delight in the Bahamas.

Fish Fry St, Nassau
4.2 Very Good 106 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/flyin-pig-cafe

Flyin' Pig Cafe

Experience delightful dining at Flyin' Pig Cafe in Staniel Cay - where every meal is made with love and local ingredients.

B&G Highway, Airport Rd, Staniel Cay
4.2 Very Good 9 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/the-midnight-spot

The Midnight Spot

Discover authentic Bahamian cuisine at The Midnight Spot, where fresh seafood meets vibrant island culture in Nassau.

Potter's Cay Dock #2 Nassau N.P
4.6 Excellent 59 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/staniel-cay-yacht-club-restaurant

Staniel Cay Yacht Club Restaurant

Experience exquisite Bahamian cuisine at Staniel Cay Yacht Club Restaurant while soaking in stunning ocean views.

5HC4+V2G, Staniel Cay, The Bahamas, Black Point
4.5 Excellent 19 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/ty-s-sunset-bar-grill

TY´s Sunset Bar & Grill

Experience local flavors and breathtaking sunsets at TY's Sunset Bar & Grill on Little Farmer's Cay - a true Bahamian gem.

Little Farmer's Cay
4.3 Very Good 37 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/kaye-s-bar

Kaye's Bar

Experience authentic Bahamian culture at Kaye's Bar in Port Nelson—where tropical drinks meet friendly faces.

Port Nelson
4.8 Excellent 25 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/scorpios-inn-restaurant-bar

Scorpios inn restaurant & bar

Discover authentic Bahamian flavors at Scorpios Inn Restaurant & Bar on Great Guana Cay - where culinary delights meet breathtaking views.

3HWX+82F, Great Guana Cay, Black Point
4.9 Excellent 14 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/the-hill-house-restaurant-at-fowl-cay-resort

The Hill House Restaurant at Fowl Cay Resort

Discover exquisite dining at The Hill House Restaurant in Fowl Cay Resort, where local flavors meet stunning ocean views.

5GMV+79J Fowl Cay, Fowl Cay Resort
4.6 Excellent 9 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/two-sisters-takeaway

Two Sisters Takeaway

Experience authentic Bahamian seafood at Two Sisters Takeaway in Port Nelson - fresh flavors that celebrate local traditions.

M527+83M, Port Nelson
4.3 Very Good 3 reviews
the-bahamas/rum-cay/restaurant/rum-cay-drive-13-shena-s

Rum Cay Drive #13 (Shena's)

Experience authentic Bahamian flavors at Shena's Grill in Eight Mile Rock—where every dish tells a story.

Bayshore rd Eight Mile Rock Grand Bahama
4.4 Very Good 10 reviews

More to explore in Rum Cay

Jump into the most useful discovery pages nearby, from experiences and heritage highlights to food, stays, shopping, and evening ideas.

photo
Destination guide

More about Rum Cay

Discover Rum Cay in The Bahamas: a serene island paradise with pristine beaches, vibrant marine life, and rich history, perfect for relaxation and adventure.

Tell me more about Rum Cay
Mobile App
Get the app

Your all‑in‑one travel companion app

Explore expert travel guides, compare and book tours, experiences, hotels, and more—all from the palm of your hand. Download now for seamless trip planning wherever your wanderlust takes you.

Select Currency

Choose the currency you want prices to display in.