The Pickled Herring: A Culinary Gem in Bayfield
Discover the best of Bayfield dining at The Pickled Herring, where fresh flavors meet a vibrant atmosphere.
Nestled in the picturesque town of Bayfield, Wisconsin, The Pickled Herring is a must-visit grill that offers a delightful dining experience with a focus on fresh, local ingredients and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're indulging in their signature dishes or enjoying a refreshing drink at the bar, this spot is perfect for tourists seeking a taste of the region.
A brief summary to The Pickled Herring
- 1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, Wisconsin, 54814, US
- +1715-779-3330
- Tuesday 11 am-9:30 pm
- Wednesday 11 am-9:30 pm
- Thursday 11 am-9:30 pm
- Friday 11 am-10 pm
- Saturday 11 am-10 pm
- Sunday 3 pm-8:30 pm
Local tips
- Visit during weekday lunch hours for a quieter dining experience.
- Try the daily specials for unique and seasonal dishes.
- Don’t forget to check out the drink menu; their craft cocktails are a highlight.
- Make a reservation during the busy summer season to secure your table.
- Ask the staff for recommendations on the best local attractions to visit after your meal.
Discover more about The Pickled Herring
Iconic landmarks you can’t miss
All Hands Sailing
0.1 km
Explore the stunning waters of Lake Superior with All Hands Sailing in Bayfield, Wisconsin – where adventure and beautiful scenery await every sailor.
Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining
0.1 km
Experience the warmth and flavors of Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining in Bayfield, where cozy accommodations meet delightful American cuisine amid stunning scenery.
Apostle Islands Booksellers
0.1 km
Discover the charm of Apostle Islands Booksellers in Bayfield, Wisconsin - a haven for book lovers and a gateway to local literature and culture.
The Isaac Wing House
0.1 km
Discover the charm of The Isaac Wing House in Bayfield, Wisconsin, your perfect retreat for relaxation and exploration by the harbor.
Bayfield on the Lake Unit #201
0.1 km
Discover the charm of Bayfield on the Lake Unit #201, your perfect lakeside retreat in Wisconsin's beautiful Bayfield.
Madeline Island Ferry - Bayfield Terminal
0.1 km
Discover the charm of Madeline Island with the scenic ferry ride from Bayfield, Wisconsin, and explore breathtaking landscapes and rich history.
Wonderstate Coffee - Bayfield
0.1 km
Discover the warmth and flavor of Wonderstate Coffee in Bayfield, where every cup is crafted with passion and a love for local ingredients.
Sweet Sailing
0.1 km
Explore the sweet side of Bayfield at Sweet Sailing, a charming candy store offering a delightful array of handmade confections and treats for all ages.
Trek & Trail
0.2 km
Experience the breathtaking beauty of Bayfield, WI with Trek & Trail's canoeing, kayaking, and biking adventures in the Apostle Islands.
St. James Social
0.2 km
Discover St. James Social in Bayfield, WI, where exquisite dining, a vibrant bar, and a cozy coffee shop await in a picturesque setting.
Apostle Islands Kayaking Rustic Makwa Den
0.2 km
Discover the Unmatched Beauty of Apostle Islands Kayaking - An Adventure Through Nature's Wonderland on Lake Superior.
Joanne's Scandinavian
0.3 km
Discover unique Scandinavian gifts and local treasures at Joanne's Scandinavian, a charming gift shop in scenic Bayfield, Wisconsin.
At Ships Quarters
0.3 km
Discover the charm of Bayfield, Wisconsin, with a serene stay at Ships Quarters, a cozy hotel near the breathtaking shores of Lake Superior.
Bayfield Apple Festival
0.3 km
Discover the vibrant Bayfield Apple Festival in Wisconsin, a perfect blend of local culture, delicious apple treats, and community spirit.
Bayfield Chamber & Visitor Bureau
0.3 km
Experience the natural beauty and cultural richness of Bayfield, Wisconsin - your perfect escape on the shores of Lake Superior.
Unmissable attractions to see
Bayfield Lakeside Pavilion
0.0 km
Experience the breathtaking views and natural beauty at Bayfield Lakeside Pavilion, a premier event venue on the shores of Lake Superior.
Bayfield Civic League - Memorial Park
0.0 km
Discover the natural beauty of Bayfield Civic League - Memorial Park, where stunning lake views and peaceful trails await every visitor.
Madeline Island Ferry
0.1 km
Experience the breathtaking ride across Lake Superior with the Madeline Island Ferry, connecting you to stunning landscapes and outdoor adventures.
Washington Avenue Beach
0.2 km
Washington Avenue Beach in Bayfield, WI, is a stunning lakeside retreat perfect for relaxation, sunbathing, and enjoying breathtaking views of Lake Superior.
Old Bayfield City Jail
0.2 km
Discover the intriguing history of the Old Bayfield City Jail, a significant landmark showcasing Bayfield's rich past and architectural charm.
Bayfield Heritage Association Inc
0.3 km
Uncover the fascinating history of Bayfield, Wisconsin at the Bayfield Heritage Association, where the past comes alive through engaging exhibits and artifacts.
Bayfield Heritage Research
0.3 km
Explore the Bayfield Heritage Research for an immersive journey into the local history and culture of Wisconsin's picturesque Bayfield.
Bayfield Maritime Museum
0.3 km
Discover the rich maritime heritage of the Great Lakes at the Bayfield Maritime Museum in Wisconsin, a captivating attraction for all ages.
Marina park & Playground
0.3 km
Explore the beauty of Marina Park & Playground in Bayfield, WI - a perfect family-friendly destination with scenic views and outdoor fun.
The Knight House
0.4 km
Explore The Knight House, a historical landmark in Bayfield, Wisconsin, and step back in time to experience the town's rich heritage.
Halvor Reiten Park and Public Beach
0.5 km
Discover the beauty of Halvor Reiten Park and Public Beach in Bayfield, WI, where nature meets serenity amidst stunning views of Lake Superior.
Dobson Park
0.5 km
Experience the tranquility and beauty of Dobson Park in Bayfield, Wisconsin. A perfect escape for nature lovers and peace seekers.
Apostle Islands National Lakeshore Headquarters
0.6 km
Explore the stunning Apostle Islands National Lakeshore Headquarters in Bayfield, Wisconsin, your gateway to breathtaking landscapes and outdoor adventures on Lake Superior.
Big Ravine - West Rim Trail
0.8 km
Explore the breathtaking Big Ravine - West Rim Trail in Bayfield, Wisconsin, where nature's beauty and adventure await every hiker.
Fountain Garden Park
1.0 km
Experience the serene beauty of Fountain Garden Park in Bayfield, WI, where vibrant gardens and tranquil fountains create the perfect outdoor escape.
Essential places to dine
The Pickled Herring
0.0 km
Discover delicious grilled dishes at The Pickled Herring in Bayfield, where local flavors meet stunning lake views.
Pier Plaza Restaurant
0.0 km
Experience exquisite dining at Pier Plaza Restaurant in Bayfield - where local flavors meet stunning lake views.
Pier Plaza Lodging
0.0 km
Experience comfort at Pier Plaza Lodging in Bayfield, WI - your gateway to stunning Lake Superior views and unforgettable adventures.
The Deck
0.1 km
Discover The Deck: A scenic bar in Bayfield offering breathtaking views of Lake Superior and delightful local cuisine.
The Bayfield Inn
0.1 km
Discover unparalleled hospitality at The Bayfield Inn – your gateway to Lake Superior's stunning landscapes and rich local culture.
Morty's Pub
0.1 km
Discover Morty's Pub in Bayfield: Where Craft Beer Meets Cozy Atmosphere for an Unforgettable Dining Experience.
The Creamery Bar
0.2 km
Discover Bayfield's charm at The Creamery Bar—your go-to spot for refreshing drinks and delicious bar food amidst scenic beauty.
Manypenny Bistro
0.2 km
Discover Manypenny Bistro in Bayfield: where local flavors meet cozy charm in every bite.
Hendrickson House & Carriage House
0.3 km
Experience comfort and tranquility at Hendrickson House & Carriage House in scenic Bayfield, Wisconsin—your perfect retreat near Lake Superior.
Landmark Restaurant At Old Rittenhouse Inn
0.4 km
Experience fine dining at its best at the Landmark Restaurant in Bayfield - where exquisite cuisine meets stunning lake views.
Gourmet Garage
1.4 km
Discover Gourmet Garage in Bayfield: A bakery paradise offering fresh pastries and artisan breads that showcase the essence of Wisconsin's culinary scene.
Superior Taco Truck
2.0 km
Experience authentic Mexican flavors at Superior Taco Truck in Bayfield, WI – where delicious tacos meet stunning natural beauty.
Portside
3.9 km
Savor the flavors of America at Portside while enjoying breathtaking waterfront views in beautiful Bayfield, Wisconsin.
Farmhouse Kitchen and Inn
3.9 km
Discover the Farmhouse Kitchen and Inn on Madeline Island for fresh local cuisine in a cozy setting surrounded by nature's beauty.
Beach Club on Madeline Island
4.1 km
Discover delicious grilled cuisine at Beach Club on Madeline Island with breathtaking views of Lake Superior.
Markets, malls and hidden boutiques
Dessert Dock
0.0 km
Experience the best artisanal ice cream at Dessert Dock in Bayfield, Wisconsin—where every scoop is a taste of local charm and delight.
Keeper of the Light
0.0 km
Explore the artistic spirit of Bayfield at Keeper of the Light, where unique gifts and local craftsmanship come together in a charming setting.
Howl Downtown
0.1 km
Discover unique fashion and local artistry at Howl Downtown in Bayfield, a must-visit clothing store for every traveler.
Starlit Kitchen
0.1 km
Discover the flavors of Bayfield at Starlit Kitchen, where delicious sandwiches and fresh baked goods await in a cozy atmosphere.
Captain's Spirits
0.1 km
Explore the best selection of local and international spirits at Captain's Spirits in Bayfield, Wisconsin, a true gem for liquor lovers.
Brownstone Centre
0.1 km
Explore the charming Brownstone Centre in Bayfield, WI - your destination for unique gifts and local crafts that capture the spirit of the area.
Roxanne's
0.2 km
Explore Roxanne's gift shop in Bayfield, WI, where unique local treasures await every visitor.
Up North
0.2 km
Explore Up North in Bayfield, Wisconsin – a charming clothing and souvenir store offering unique gifts, local crafts, and delightful toys for all ages.
SIlverwaves Jewelry
0.2 km
Explore Silverwaves Jewelry in Bayfield, WI for unique and exquisite handcrafted pieces that capture the essence of artisan craftsmanship.
Penny Print Studio
0.2 km
Explore Penny Print Studio in Bayfield, Wisconsin, a vibrant art studio and boutique celebrating local creativity through unique prints and handcrafted treasures.
Field Day Market
0.2 km
Explore Field Day Market, your go-to natural goods store in Bayfield, Wisconsin, for organic foods and local artisanal treasures.
Andy's IGA
0.2 km
Discover the heart of Bayfield at Andy's IGA, where local flavors and everyday essentials meet in a welcoming grocery store experience.
Honest Dog Books
0.2 km
Explore Honest Dog Books in Bayfield, Wisconsin, a charming bookstore offering a rich selection of literature and a cozy atmosphere for all book lovers.
Good Flower Farm
0.2 km
Explore Good Flower Farm in Bayfield, WI: a unique boutique offering natural cosmetics and a delightful shopping experience amidst stunning landscapes.
Stone's Throw
0.2 km
Discover unique local art and handcrafted gifts at Stone's Throw, an inviting gallery in the heart of Bayfield, Wisconsin.
Essential bars & hidden hideouts
Bayfield Wine And Spirits
0.2 km
Discover the finest selection of local and international wines and spirits at Bayfield Wine and Spirits in beautiful Bayfield, Wisconsin.
Clipper Brewing Company
0.4 km
Experience unique craft beers in a cozy brewery atmosphere at Clipper Brewing Company, where local flavors meet exceptional brewing artistry.
Adventure Club Brewing
2.0 km
Discover the vibrant flavors of craft beer at Adventure Club Brewing in Bayfield, Wisconsin – a brewery experience like no other.
Mission Hill Coffee House
4.1 km
Experience the warmth and flavor at Mission Hill Coffee House, La Pointe's cozy coffee haven with artisanal brews and delightful pastries.
