Best Restaurants in Peter Island

35 restaurants

1. 
   01
   Restaurant4.4★1,056 reviews

   The Smoking Rooster

   The Smoking Rooster is a lively open-air BBQ restaurant in St. Thomas, serving tender ribs, brisket, and generous portions on cafeteria trays. Located near cruise ship docks in Charlotte Amalie, it offers casual outdoor dining with cold beers, cocktails, and a fun vibe perfect for visitors seeking authentic island barbecue.

   Daily 11:00–22:00Price level $$Time to spend 0.8–2 hrs

   74 min drive · 37 km·83MH+5QW, St Thomas 00802

   Show on map The Smoking Rooster
2. 
   02
   Restaurant4.3★865 reviews

   Tap and Still Havensight

   Tap and Still Havensight is a laid-back sports bar and brewery in St. Thomas' Havensight Mall, celebrated for juicy customizable burgers, fresh-cut fries, and a robust selection of craft beers and cocktails. With indoor and outdoor seating, it's a casual spot for cruise passengers and locals to unwind amid shopping convenience and lively vibes. Expect paper-bag deliveries, happy hour specials like $3 Carib beers, and friendly service in a breezy Caribbean setting.

   Price level $Time to spend 0.5–2 hrs

   73 min drive · 37 km·18°20'00.5N 64°55'11 Havensight Mall St Thomas, St Thomas 00802

   Show on map Tap and Still Havensight
3. 
   03
   Restaurant4.0★648 reviews

   The Delly Deck

   The Delly Deck is a casual diner and bar in Havensight Shopping Mall, St. Thomas, serving hearty breakfasts, juicy burgers, fresh salads, and local favorites like johnny cakes all day. With indoor air-conditioned seating and open-air options, it offers table service, takeout, and vegetarian-friendly dishes in a lively cruise port spot perfect for quick, flavorful meals.

   Mon–Sat 7:00–15:00 · Sun 8:00–15:00Price level $Time to spend 0.5–1.5 hrs

   74 min drive · 37 km·St. Thomas, Havensight Shopping Mall, Building 3, 00802

   Show on map The Delly Deck
4. 
   04
   Restaurant4.5★411 reviews

   Pirates Bight

   Nestled on the stunning Norman Island in the British Virgin Islands, Pirates Bight is a must-visit restaurant for tourists seeking delicious Caribbean cuisine and breathtaking views. With its vibrant atmosphere and friendly service, it promises an unforgettable dining experience.

   Daily 11:00–21:00

   11 min drive · 5.7 km·Norman Island, British Virgin Islands

   Show on map Pirates Bight
5. 
   05
   Pizza4.2★419 reviews

   Pie Whole Pizza

   Pie Whole Pizza in Charlotte Amalie's Frenchtown serves wood-fired pizzas, wings, pasta, and salads in a lively outdoor patio setting. Known for its casual vibe, pet-friendly atmosphere, and accommodating staff, it draws locals and visitors alike. Open daily from noon to 9 PM with moderate prices and a 4.2-star rating from hundreds of reviews.

   Tue–Sun 12:00–21:00Price level $$Time to spend 0.5–2 hrs

   78 min drive · 39 km·24a U.S. Virgin Islands, Honduras, Charlotte Amalie, 00802

   Show on map Pie Whole Pizza
6. 
   06
   Hotel4.6★315 reviews

   Cooper Island Beach Club

   Nestled in the serene waters of the British Virgin Islands, Cooper Island Beach Club offers a unique blend of relaxation and adventure. With its stunning beach views, delectable dining options, and comfortable accommodations, it's an idyllic getaway for any traveler looking to experience the Caribbean's natural beauty.

   15 min drive · 7.3 km·9FPP+6X7, Manchioneel Bay Cooper Island, Cooper Island VG1110, British Virgin Islands

   Show on map Cooper Island Beach Club
7. 
   07
   Mexican restaurant4.4★229 reviews

   Agave - Havensight

   Agave - Havensight brings vibrant Mexican flavors to St. Thomas' Havensight Mall. Savor handmade tortillas, fresh salsas, creative tacos like pineapple-coconut carnitas and chimichurri carne asada, plus a stellar tequila and mezcal selection. Modern Tex-Mex twists in a warm, lively setting perfect for lunch or dinner daily from 11am-10pm.

   Daily 11:00–22:00Price level $$Time to spend 0.8–2 hrs

   73 min drive · 37 km·Havensight Mall, Rte 30, St Thomas, 00802

   Show on map Agave - Havensight
8. 
   08
   Italian4.5★150 reviews

   Capriccio di Mare

   Nestled along the picturesque waterfront of Road Town, Capriccio di Mare offers a delightful escape for tourists craving authentic Italian cuisine. With a stunning view and a menu that captures the essence of Italy, it's a must-visit for food lovers.

   18 min drive · 8.9 km·Waterfront Dr, Road Town, British Virgin Islands

   Show on map Capriccio di Mare
9. 
   09
   Grill4.4★149 reviews

   The Watering Hole

   Nestled in the heart of Road Town, The Watering Hole is a vibrant grill that offers a delightful fusion of local flavors and international cuisine, perfect for tourists seeking a memorable dining experience.

   Mon–Sat 7:30–22:30

   18 min drive · 9.2 km·Wikham's Cay, Road Town, Tortola Road Town, VG1110, British Virgin Islands

   Show on map The Watering Hole
10. 
    10
    Restaurant4.7★119 reviews

    Omar's Fusion

    Nestled in the picturesque Soper's Hole, Omar's Fusion is a must-visit restaurant for tourists seeking an unforgettable dining experience in the British Virgin Islands. With a diverse menu that beautifully blends local flavors and international cuisine, this eatery is perfect for food enthusiasts looking to indulge in fresh, delicious dishes while enjoying stunning views of the marina.

    Daily 7:00–22:00

    28 min drive · 14 km·Soper's Hole, Tortola, British Virgin Islands

    Show on map Omar's Fusion