A Slice of Paradise: Bethany Beach's Beloved Pie Haven
Explore the best of Bethany Beach with a visit to this renowned pizza restaurant, where every slice is a delicious journey into flavor.
Nestled in the picturesque town of Bethany Beach, this pizza haven is a must-visit for tourists seeking delicious, freshly made pies. With its warm atmosphere and inviting menu, it’s the perfect spot to unwind after a day of beach fun.
A brief summary to Pie
- 20 N Pennsylvania Ave, Bethany Beach, Delaware, 19930, US
- +1302-539-2600
- Visit website
Local tips
- Arrive early, especially on weekends, to secure a table as it gets busy quickly.
- Try their specialty pizzas that feature local ingredients for a unique taste.
- Don’t miss out on the seasonal specials; they often have unique flavors that are not on the regular menu.
Getting There
-
Walking
If you're starting from the Bethany Beach Boardwalk, head north on Atlantic Avenue until you reach Garfield Parkway. Turn left onto Garfield Parkway and continue walking until you reach Pennsylvania Avenue. Turn right onto Pennsylvania Avenue, and Pie will be on your left at 20 N Pennsylvania Ave. The walk should take about 15-20 minutes.
-
Biking
Rent a bike from one of the local rental shops in Bethany Beach. Start from the Boardwalk and head north on Atlantic Avenue. When you hit Garfield Parkway, turn left and bike until you reach Pennsylvania Avenue. Turn right onto Pennsylvania Avenue, and Pie will be on your left at 20 N Pennsylvania Ave. The biking route should take around 10 minutes.
-
Public Transportation
Check with local bus services for routes heading towards the main area of Bethany Beach. You can board the DART bus service (if available) and ask the driver to let you off at the closest stop to Pennsylvania Avenue. From there, walk a short distance to reach Pie at 20 N Pennsylvania Ave.
Discover more about Pie
Iconic landmarks you can’t miss
Pie
0.0 km
Explore the best of Bethany Beach with a visit to this renowned pizza restaurant, where every slice is a delicious journey into flavor.
Japanesque
0.0 km
Explore the vibrant selection of unique clothing and gifts at Japanesque in Bethany Beach, Delaware - where culture meets style.
Monument Sotheby's International Realty - Coastal Division
0.1 km
Discover luxurious coastal living in Bethany Beach with Monument Sotheby's International Realty, where dream homes await along the stunning Atlantic coastline.
14 Global
0.1 km
Discover the vibrant culinary scene at 14 Global, where a world of tapas awaits in the heart of Bethany Beach.
Bethany Blues BBQ Pit
0.1 km
Indulge in authentic barbecue flavors at Bethany Blues BBQ Pit in Bethany Beach, Delaware - a family-friendly haven for food lovers.
Candy Kitchen
0.2 km
Explore Candy Kitchen in Bethany Beach for an unforgettable sweet experience with a wide selection of candies and chocolates, perfect for all ages!
Beach Break & Bakrie
0.2 km
Discover the delightful flavors of American cuisine at Beach Break & Bakrie, a charming café and bakery in Bethany Beach, Delaware.
Sandy Pony Donuts
0.2 km
Indulge in the freshest, most delicious donuts at Sandy Pony Donuts in Bethany Beach, where every bite brings a taste of coastal charm.
Central Blvd Parking Lot
0.2 km
Discover the charm of Bethany Beach with easy parking at Central Blvd Parking Lot, your gateway to local attractions, shops, and dining experiences.
Ropewalk Bethany Beach
0.2 km
Experience the finest seafood and vibrant coastal atmosphere at Ropewalk Bethany Beach, a dining gem along Delaware's picturesque coastline.
The Penguin
0.2 km
Experience the charm of The Penguin in Bethany Beach, where delicious brunch meets a warm, family-friendly atmosphere.
Bethany Beach Comics and Gaming
0.2 km
Explore the magical world of comics and gaming in Bethany Beach, DE - a must-visit for fans of all ages!
Pomodoro Pizzeria
0.2 km
Discover the taste of authentic Italian pizza at Pomodoro Pizzeria, a beloved gem in Bethany Beach, Delaware.
Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard
0.2 km
Discover the iconic Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard in Bethany Beach, where every scoop is a deliciously sweet escape for beachgoers and tourists alike.
Rhodes 5 & 10
0.2 km
Explore Rhodes 5 & 10 in Bethany Beach for a unique variety of beach essentials, souvenirs, and local treasures that capture the spirit of Delaware's coastline.
Unmissable attractions to see
Shore Fun Family Fun Center
0.2 km
Bethany Beach's premier family fun arcade, offering a wide variety of games and entertainment for all ages. Clean, safe, and fun!
Chief Little Owl
0.2 km
A towering tribute to the Nanticoke tribe, Chief Little Owl stands as a landmark and symbol of Bethany Beach, Delaware, since 1976.
Bethany Beach Boardwalk
0.3 km
Discover the enchanting charm of Bethany Beach Boardwalk, where sun, sea, and vibrant culture meet in perfect harmony.
Bethany Beach Bandstand
0.3 km
Experience live music and community spirit at the Bethany Beach Bandstand, the heart of entertainment on the boardwalk.
Bethany Beach History Museum
0.4 km
Explore the vibrant history of Bethany Beach at the local history museum, where engaging exhibits celebrate the town's rich heritage and culture.
Bethany Beach Dinker-Irvin Museum
0.4 km
Explore Bethany Beach's past at the Dinker-Irvin Museum, a preserved 1900s cottage and former post office showcasing local history and heritage.
Bethany Beach Nature Center
1.4 km
Explore the serene Bethany Beach Nature Center, a haven for wildlife and nature lovers, showcasing Delaware's rich ecosystems and educational experiences.
South Bethany Beach
3.2 km
Escape to South Bethany Beach: Delaware's best-kept secret for serene beaches, family fun, and tranquil coastal relaxation.
WWII Observation Tower #1 - Rehoboth Beach
3.8 km
Explore a piece of WWII history at this coastal observation tower in Fenwick Island, offering scenic views and a glimpse into the past.
James Farm Ecological Preserve
4.3 km
Explore diverse habitats, hike scenic trails, and discover the beauty of Delaware's Inland Bays at this 150-acre ecological preserve.
The Millville Boardwalk
5.5 km
Delmarva's premier family-friendly entertainment destination with mini-golf, homemade ice cream, arcade games, go-karts, and live entertainment.
Assawoman Wildlife Area
5.7 km
Discover Delaware's natural beauty: Explore diverse habitats, observe wildlife, and enjoy peaceful outdoor recreation at Assawoman Wildlife Area.
Fishing access
6.4 km
Access coastal Delaware's rich fishing grounds from Fenwick Island; surf fishing, bay fishing, and a relaxing beach atmosphere await.
South Inlet, Delaware Seashore State Park
7.4 km
Discover pristine beaches, thrilling water sports, and stunning coastal views at South Inlet, Delaware Seashore State Park – a perfect seaside getaway.
Fenwick Island State Park
7.6 km
Discover pristine beaches, tranquil waters, and historical landmarks at Delaware's southernmost coastal escape, Fenwick Island State Park.
Essential places to dine
Sedona
0.0 km
Discover Sedona in Bethany Beach: where exquisite American cuisine meets vibrant bar culture for an unforgettable dining experience.
Patsy's Restaurant
0.1 km
Discover the flavors of the sea at Patsy's Restaurant in Bethany Beach - where fresh seafood meets American comfort cuisine.
Five Guys
0.2 km
Experience the best of American fast food at Five Guys in Bethany Beach – fresh burgers, crispy fries, and delicious shakes await!
Baja Beach House Grill
0.2 km
Experience delicious Mexican-American cuisine with live music at Baja Beach House Grill in beautiful Bethany Beach.
The Blue Crab
0.2 km
Discover delectable seafood at The Blue Crab in Bethany Beach - where fresh flavors meet coastal charm.
The Parkway Restaurant
0.2 km
Experience fresh seafood and American classics at The Parkway Restaurant in Bethany Beach - a culinary delight by the shore.
Steve's Sugar Shack
0.2 km
Experience the sweetest side of Bethany Beach at Steve's Sugar Shack – where delectable desserts and warm hospitality await every visitor.
3BB Cafe
0.2 km
Experience the best of Bethany Beach at 3BB Cafe, where delicious coffee meets homemade pastries in a cozy setting.
DB's Seafood Co
0.2 km
Discover fresh seafood delights at DB's Seafood Co in Bethany Beach – your ultimate destination for ocean-inspired culinary experiences.
Surfs up
0.3 km
Experience delicious fast food at Surfs Up in Bethany Beach—a perfect pit stop for beach lovers seeking tasty treats!
Sunshine Crepes
0.3 km
Discover the flavors of Europe at Sunshine Crepes in Bethany Beach - where delicious crepes meet a cozy atmosphere.
Mango's
0.3 km
Experience vibrant Caribbean flavors at Mango's in Bethany Beach - where every meal feels like a tropical getaway.
Shore Break
0.3 km
Discover delectable dishes with local flavors at Shore Break in Bethany Beach—your seaside dining destination.
ZOCA Mexican Restaurant - Bethany Beach
0.3 km
Experience authentic Mexican cuisine at ZOCA Mexican Restaurant in Bethany Beach - perfect for families and food lovers!
Harvest Tide Steakhouse, Bethany Beach, DE
0.3 km
Discover the exquisite flavors at Harvest Tide Steakhouse in Bethany Beach - where premium steaks meet coastal charm.
Markets, malls and hidden boutiques
Alice & Laila
0.1 km
Explore Alice & Laila in Bethany Beach for a unique selection of women's couture, accessories, and jewelry that elevate your style.
Gypsy Teal
0.1 km
Explore Gypsy Teal for unique clothing and accessories that capture the essence of beach style in Bethany Beach, Delaware.
Palms At Bethany
0.2 km
Discover trendy clothing and accessories at Palms At Bethany, your go-to fashion destination in the heart of Bethany Beach, Delaware.
Atlantic Shoals Surf Shop
0.2 km
Explore the ultimate surf and beach shop in Bethany Beach, offering quality gear, apparel, and a taste of the coastal lifestyle.
Delmarva Dry Goods
0.2 km
Discover unique clothing and upscale gifts at Delmarva Dry Goods in Bethany Beach, Delaware, the perfect stop for stylish souvenirs.
Blue Room Gallery and Gift Shop
0.2 km
Explore the vibrant Blue Room Gallery and Gift Shop in Bethany Beach, where local art meets unique gifts and coastal charm.
Sun and Sea
0.2 km
Explore Sun and Sea in Bethany Beach for stylish beachwear and accessories, ensuring a perfect day under the sun.
Freaky Tiki Teez
0.2 km
Discover unique beach-themed clothing and accessories at Freaky Tiki Teez in Bethany Beach, the perfect stop for tourists seeking stylish souvenirs.
Sea Shirts
0.2 km
Explore Sea Shirts in Bethany Beach for stylish beachwear and accessories, embodying the essence of coastal living.
Su Casa
0.2 km
Discover unique coastal furniture and home decor at Su Casa, your go-to destination in Bethany Beach for a stylish beachside living experience.
Tangerine Goods
0.2 km
Explore the enchanting Tangerine Goods in Bethany Beach for unique fashion accessories that capture the essence of coastal style.
Fells Point Surf Co
0.2 km
Explore Fells Point Surf Co in Bethany Beach for surf gear, stylish clothing, and unique gifts that embody the coastal spirit.
Fish Tales
0.2 km
Explore Fish Tales, a charming boutique in Bethany Beach, DE, offering unique beach clothing and accessories for your coastal adventures.
Kites Tails & Toys
0.2 km
Explore the vibrant world of kites and toys at Kites Tails & Toys in Bethany Beach, a must-visit for unique gifts and family fun.
Bethany Trading Company
0.2 km
Explore a whimsical world of toys and gifts at Bethany Trading Company, where imagination knows no bounds in Bethany Beach, DE.
Essential bars & hidden hideouts
Ocean View Brewing Company
3.3 km
Discover the essence of local craft beer at Ocean View Brewing Company, a vibrant brewpub in Delaware with a menu that delights every palate.
Hooked Up Ale House & Raw Bar
4.5 km
Discover Hooked Up Ale House & Raw Bar: A seafood lover's paradise in Millville, DE, with fresh catches and a vibrant sports ambiance.
Dockside Marina Bar + Grill
8.2 km
Discover Dockside Marina Bar + Grill, where fresh seafood meets stunning waterfront views in the heart of Rehoboth Beach, Delaware.
The Tavern
9.0 km
Experience the charm of The Tavern in Selbyville, where cozy atmosphere meets delightful drinks and local hospitality.
Coastal Cravings
9.5 km
Experience the ultimate brunch getaway at Coastal Cravings in Fenwick Island, where fresh coastal flavors meet a relaxed dining atmosphere.
Rusty Jimmies Seafood Market & Eatery
9.5 km
Experience the best of Fenwick Island's seafood scene at Rusty Jimmies, where delicious crab dishes and local flavors await.
Ocean Side
9.6 km
Discover the culinary delights of Ocean Side, where fresh seafood meets coastal charm in Fenwick Island, Delaware.
Seaside Bar & Grill
9.6 km
Experience the essence of coastal dining at Seaside Bar & Grill, featuring fresh seafood, hearty grills, and breathtaking waterfront views.
Fenwick Island
9.6 km
Experience the serene charm of Fenwick Island, Delaware – a coastal paradise with stunning beaches, local shops, and delicious seafood.
Vista Rooftop
10.7 km
Discover Vista Rooftop: A Culinary Gem Offering Stunning Ocean Views and Exquisite Dining in Ocean City, Maryland.
Taphouse Tavern
10.8 km
Dive into delicious grilled flavors and vibrant nightlife at Taphouse Tavern in Ocean City, MD, a perfect blend of dining and entertainment.
Yellowfin's Bar & Grill
11.1 km
Discover the flavors of the coast at Yellowfin's Bar & Grill, where fresh seafood meets a vibrant atmosphere in Selbyville, Delaware.
Paradise Grill
11.2 km
Savor delicious grilled dishes and refreshing drinks at Paradise Grill, Millsboro's favorite waterfront bar and restaurant.
Beach Barrels
11.3 km
Experience the vibrant beach bar atmosphere at Beach Barrels in Ocean City, Maryland, where refreshing drinks and delicious snacks await.
Paradise Pub
11.3 km
Discover the vibrant flavors of Paradise Pub in Millsboro, Delaware, where delicious grill cuisine meets a lively pub atmosphere.
